Skip to main content

The Schein Nine

Mark Sanchez has New York Jets among teams needing new QB

Move past the greatness of guys like Peyton Manning, Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers. Have you noticed how bad quarterback play has been in the NFL this year? It's been worse than ever.

Christian Ponder can't complete the forward pass for the Minnesota Vikings. Jake Locker makes you cringe with the Tennessee Titans. I've chronicled the follies of Joe Flacco, who has taken an alarming step backward this season for the Baltimore Ravens. But realistically, all three will be back under center for their respective clubs next year, for a variety of reasons.

In this edition of The Schein Nine, I present nine teams that absolutely must be in the quarterback business next year in some way, shape or form, and how they each should address the position.

1) Arizona Cardinals

I don't know if "Kolb-Skelton-Lindley" is a quarterback group or a punch line. This is the single worst trio of quarterbacks I have ever seen.

I supported the trade that brought Kevin Kolb to Arizona from the Philadelphia Eagles in 2011. I thought Ken Whisenhunt was the right guy to coach him. However, I also suggested then that the Cardinals needed a legit veteran backup, as Kolb had never been a 16-game NFL starter.

Failing to find one proved to be a major mistake. Kolb was slow to learn the playbook after the lockout, and he never dazzled his teammates or coaches with leadership or his play.

This group needs a purge, a cleansing. The Cards liked rookie Ryan Lindley as a developmental draft pick. And that's what he is. Kolb and John Skelton, meanwhile, will be long gone. They represent failure. The Cardinals need someone stable.

Signing Alex Smith, if the San Francisco 49ers let him go rather than give him his roster bonus next spring, would be a savvy move. Smith likely wouldn't be available via trade, however, as the Niners won't deal him to another NFC West team.

I would offer the Washington Redskins a second-round draft pick to pry Kirk Cousins loose. I would offer the New England Patriots a second-round pick for Ryan Mallett, too.

I wouldn't spend a first-round pick on a quarterback, though. As bad as Arizona's quarterback play is, the offensive line is actually worse. The team also will need to add another backup signal-caller.

2) New York Jets

Mark Sanchez should never throw another pass for the New York Jets.

Sanchez is not a legit NFL quarterback. I wrote that sentence before he threw four picks and fumbled in the final minute against the Tennessee Titans on Monday, dooming the Jets' playoff chances.

Sanchez should've been benched after the pick he threw on third-and-goal against the Seattle Seahawks in Week 10. Failing that, he should have lost his spot atop the depth chart after third-stringer Greg McElroy replaced him against the Arizona Cardinals in Week 13, sparking the Jets to a win. Yet, somehow, the clueless Rex Ryan stayed with Sanchez, while McElroy was inactive in Weeks 14 and 15. That's irresponsible.

(UPDATE: It does appear that the Jets are finally interested in seeing more of what they have in McElroy, who was named the starter on Tuesday for the upcoming game against the San Diego Chargers.)

Lombardi: Jets must get honest

Michael Lombardi says it's time for Rex Ryan and the Jets to stop kidding themselves and take a hard look at their roster. **More ...**

The Jets guaranteed Sanchez's deal to the tune of $8.25 million next year. Releasing him would reportedly garner a whopping $17 million cap hit. That's irrelevant. He can't ever take another snap for the Jets. His confidence is shot. His play is worse. He is, rightly, the face of underachievement and failure.

The Tim Tebow Experiment flopped miserably. The Jets need a quarterback to come in and beat out Sanchez. The Jets had Drew Stanton signed, but when they added Tebow, Stanton was traded to the Indianapolis Colts. Smith, Cousins and the Seattle Seahawks' Matt Flynn must be explored. Smith, for one, would bring the kind of consistency and leadership ability that Sanchez never will.

The Jets might also be tempted by Michael Vick, though you would think they'd stay away from him, given the Tebow nonsense. But you never know.

3) Kansas City Chiefs

The Matt Cassel-Brady Quinn carousel represents amateur hour. Sadly for the Chiefs, who are in desperate need of a young franchise quarterback, there might not be a no-brainer available at the top of the 2013 NFL Draft.

I'm sure the head coach and general manager who eventually replace Romeo Crennel and Scott Pioli will look long and hard at prospects Geno Smith and Matt Barkley. I know the knock on USC quarterbacks, and I know Barkley hurt his stock this past season. But there are also NFL executives I truly respect who thought he could play in the NFL and that he would have been a top-five pick one year ago.

Personally, I'd try to trade for Mallett or Cousins.

4) Oakland Raiders

There is a very realistic chance that Greg Knapp is one-and-done as the Raiders' offensive coordinator. If Knapp is out, there is no way a new coach with a fresh set of eyes can look at Carson Palmer as a viable quarterback.

Even if Knapp comes back next season, coach Dennis Allen must cut the cord with Palmer. He's too interception-prone. He's not a winner. Oakland needs a new stopgap (think Stanton, Kyle Orton or, dare I say, Jason Campbell?) and a young quarterback for the future. Depending on who is the offensive coordinator, I would call Seattle to try to make a trade for Flynn.

Allen gave Terrelle Pryor some snaps last week, and he said on the SiriusXM Blitz to expect to see more "Pryor packages" down the stretch. However, Pryor was drafted by the old brass, so there's a realistic chance he's a future ex-Raider.

5) Jacksonville Jaguars

If Blaine Gabbert is the answer, I'd love to know the question. The Jaguars' passing attack has functioned much better behind Chad Henne's arm and leadership than it did with Gabbert.

There could eventually be a new general manager in Jacksonville. What happens at this position depends on how that situation shakes out.

But the Jaguars shouldn't fight the obvious. They must bring in Jacksonville's favorite son: Timothy Richard Tebow.

Chances are good that Gabbert, a first-round pick in 2011, won't be eradicated. Henne, meanwhile, is solid. The Jags need a jolt of magic on the field and at the box office. Tebow can run and add energy to a rather defunct and nondescript team.

6) San Diego Chargers

Philip Rivers tossed up another clunker on Sunday. With the exception of a stunning Week 14 win over the Pittsburgh Steelers, Rivers hasn't looked like a big-time quarterback since 2010.

It's easy, and fair, to blame coach Norv Turner and general manager A.J. Smith for everything in San Diego, including the lack of talent at receiver (Vincent Jackson fled via free agency), running back (as did Darren Sproles) and along the offensive line. But watch Rivers' in-game decisions. They are horrible. His throws are awful.

Assuming Kevin Acee's reporting for *U-T San Diego* is accurate, Jimmy Raye and president Dean Spanos' son (John) will take over the role of picking players. Rivers will get another crack. But the Chargers need to draft a young potential replacement, like Syracuse's Ryan Nassib, in the third round. Charlie "Chuckles" Whitehurst is not the right guy to supplement Rivers.

7) Philadelphia Eagles

I think Vick is done, and he should be. He can't stay healthy, makes too much money and isn't the same player he once was.

I didn't love Nick Foles during the draft process. It will be fascinating to see who becomes the next coach of the Eagles, and what type of offense he'll run. If Chip Kelly takes over, I don't see Foles being the Week 1 starter in 2013.

8) Buffalo Bills

Did Ryan Fitzpatrick, a Harvard graduate, really check to a quarterback run on first-and-10?

You can't make this stuff up.

The Bills are going to draft a franchise quarterback. Why am I so sure? Well, general manager Buddy Nix keeps talking openly about it.

That mega-bucks deal Nix gave Fitzpatrick last year for eight weeks of good football has turned out to be a laughable one. Fitzpatrick will never be an upper-echelon quarterback. He's serviceable, at best.

While I see Buffalo drafting a quarterback to compete with (beat out) Fitzpatrick, Vick would be an interesting name here. Yes, he is a shell of the quarterback he used to be, but he is also the athlete with the strong arm that Chan Gailey craves (assuming, of course, that Gailey and Nix both keep their jobs).

9) Cleveland Browns

It probably isn't fair, but Brandon Weeden is in trouble. He's a 29-year-old rookie. Cleveland has a new owner. During a season dominated by the dazzling play of other rookie quarterbacks, Weeden has had an up-and-down neophyte campaign, and certainly hasn't been good enough to warrant his entrenchment.

Cleveland will likely -- and appropriately -- have a new general manager and head coach this offseason. The Browns will then bring in a veteran quarterback, either to compete with Weeden or start over him.

Follow Adam Schein on Twitter @AdamSchein.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content