Around the League

Presented By

Who are the top five NFL quarterbacks? Readers choose

NFL.com has spent much of Wednesday discussing what defines a top-shelf quarterback. (Actually, our editors used the dreaded "e" word, but Around the League made an important vow to not call anyone e---- during Super Bowl week.)

Kimberly Jones also wrote a great piece making the case that Joe Flacco is simply carrying the Baltimore Ravens in the playoffs. (Can't argue with that.) But does that really make him a top quarterback, or do you need sustained regular-season success?

We asked NFL.com readers on Twitter for their top five quarterbacks, and the results were surprising. The quarterbacks mentioned the most:

Brady and Manning nearly had identical votes. I'm shocked Rodgers wasn't higher; he would be the first guy I mentioned. I'm also surprised Flacco nearly cracked the top five. As fans, we are often too focused on wins and losses that are out of a quarterback's control.

If Denver Broncos safety Rahim Moore hadn't blown his assignment in the Broncos' divisional-round loss, I doubt Flacco would be mentioned in the top eight. Flacco is a complete quarterback who can make any throw, but he hasn't yet been consistently great over a 16-game regular-season schedule. That's what defines greatness to me.

There was a huge drop-off after Flacco in the voting. The rest of the list:

Super Debate: Kaepernick or Flacco?

colin-kaepernick-130128-IL.jpg

Starting a team from scratch, who do you take: Colin 
Kaepernick
or Joe Flacco? Our analysts provide quite a statement. More ...

Yikes. Wilson had a great rookie season, but it's insane that Roethlisberger isn't higher. He might be the most oddly underrated two-time Super Bowl champion quarterback ever. Roethlisberger has been one of the top five quarterbacks in the NFL for a long time, and he's only improved his overall game during his career.

Also notably absent: Tony Romo. Put Romo on the New York Giants or Ravens for the past decade, and I'm convinced he would have reached a Super Bowl or two.

Follow Gregg Rosenthal on Twitter @greggrosenthal.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content

Purchase single game tickets for the 2022 season