Skip to main content

Around the League

Presented By

Which 2011 playoff teams are most likely to fall short?

It's not easy getting back.

For well over a decade, we've seen roughly six playoff teams fail to make the postseason the following year.

Those are ugly numbers, but they aren't surprising. Injuries, jacked-up expectations and tougher schedules take a toll. And when the bar-room lights are flipped on, last year's darlings often reveal their flaws.

With that in mind, here are the ATL crew's predictions on who won't be back in January:

  • !
  • Gregg Rosenthal ATL editor
  • 49ers, Bengals, Broncos, Giants, Falcons and Lions

Six teams change every year, so choosing fewer would seem like a cop-out. The 49ers, Bengals and Lions are classic surprise teams that will learn a second act is much tougher. The Broncos have a brutal schedule and a lot of roster holes despite adding Peyton Manning. The Falcons and Giants easily could finish third in their own divisions.

  • !
  • Dan HanzusATL writer
  • Bengals, Lions, Ravens and Saints

Part of me wants to be "Unlikable Contrarian Guy" and just say all 12 of last year's teams will stun the football world by re-qualifying. But that won't happen. The Saints' calamitous offseason will lead to a slow start that will sink them, while the Lions and Bengals will learn it's not easy to play with the burden of expectations. And take pity on the Suggs-free Ravens, who will watch Ray Lewis and Ed Reed lose a battle with Father Time, then realize once and for all that Joe Flacco isn't El Hombre.

  • !
  • Marc SesslerATL writer
  • Bengals, Broncos, Falcons, Lions and Steelers

The Bengals haven't nailed back-to-back playoff appearances since Ronald Reagan slept in the White House. Don't hold your breath. The AFC North will eat itself up this time around, and that's where my Steelers pick comes from. In Denver, the hype doesn't make up for the holes. The Lions, meanwhile, already have been handed a playoff berth by experts, but don't forget how the Bears were 7-3 before Jay Cutler took a dirt nap. The Falcons, honestly, have lost their postseason privileges.

  • !
  • Brian McIntyreATL writer
  • 49ers, Broncos, Giants, Falcons and Steelers

As our fearless editor pointed out, there's been considerable turnover in the playoff picture from year to year. There's no rule preventing more than six teams from returning to the playoffs, though, so I'll go with five. In the AFC, Pittsburgh's young offensive line and the purging of veteran leaders hurts. It's never smart to bet against Peyton Manning, but the AFC West is wide open, and I like what I see in San Diego and Kansas City. The Giants were 7-7 at one point last season and took hits in free agency. The 49ers and Falcons might have a hard time staving off improved division opponents.

We've probably upset a few of you. Tell us about it below.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content