Skip to main content

Around the League

Presented By

NFL Divisional Power Rankings: Who's No. 1?

*It's Thursday. That means another edition of highly meaningful, random power rankings. *

We've rolled out power rankings for offenses, coaches, quarterbacks, fan bases and the most-watchable teams since the season started.

This week: The best division in football.

The NFC West has a slightly better overall record and out-of-division record. (Very slight.) The NFC North still looks stronger overall. We said before the season that there was a potential here for three playoff teams. That didn't even include the Vikings. The Bears are better than we expected, and the Packers are championship contenders until proven otherwise.

Before the season, we ranked the NFC West seventh. Old habits die hard. The NFC West has the best overall division record (15-9) and out-of-division record (12-6). The Seahawks and Cardinals beat the Patriots. The 49ers are title contenders and won in Green Bay. Four of the top five scoring defenses are in the division. The rise of the Rams as a respectable team -- they battle every week -- symbolizes the division as a whole. There are no easy outs.

Still, let's not get carried away. Arizona just lost at home to Buffalo, and San Francisco was blown away by the Giants. The NFC West is much much better, but it's not indestructible. 

Yes, the three best divisions in football are all in the NFC. The NFC East is third in overall win percentage (12-11) and out of division record (10-9), but I made this list before checking the numbers. The division passes the eyeball test: There are no embarrassing teams. There is a legitimate Super Bowl contender in New York. There is an upstart surprise in Washington.

It's pretty sad this is the best AFC division, but it's the truth. (More on that below.) The Patriots are one of the best teams in football despite their record. The Dolphins have played like a 4-2 team. We like them as the No. 6 seed in the AFC. The Jets aren't as bad as you think, and the Bills have shown they can beat bad teams.

The most disappointing AFC division is under .500 overall and out of division. The Ravens lead the way but have a lot more problems than you'd expect from a 5-1 team. The Bengals have taken a step back from last year despite their 3-3 record. The Steelers just don't look like the Steelers yet. The Browns are the one team that actually might look better than their record indicates here.

The most disappointing division in football. We pegged this as the best four-pack before the season, but that looks silly now. The Panthers' offense has collapsed, and their defense hasn't made up for it. The Saints' defense is somehow worse without Gregg Williams. The Bucs aren't an easy matchup in Year 1 under Greg Schiano. The Falcons have overcome slow starts for three consecutive weeks to stay undefeated. This remains a dangerous group, but it probably will send only one team to the playoffs.

This group climbs out of the bottom spot because there's at least one title contender here. The AFC South is a respectable 7-8 out of division. The Colts could scrape out seven to eight wins, but the Titans and Jaguars are worse than expected.

It's ugly out West. The division has two of the worst teams in football and a Chargers team that routinely blows huge leads. The Broncos look promising, but they haven't truly been competitive with the league's best. The AFC West is 4-11 out of division.

Follow Gregg Rosenthal on Twitter @greggrosenthal.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content