Skip to main content

Around the League

Presented By

Andrew Luck, RG3 won't match Newton, says scout

At some point here, we're going to reach the regular season. When we do, Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III will be scrutinized and picked apart by experts and fans alike.

Breer: Everybody loves Luck

Getting a late start on offseason practices hasn't slowed Andrew Luck. Albert Breer is thoroughly impressed. **More ...**

Luck's career with the Colts and RG3's with the Redskins will be judged side by side, but former longtime NFL scout Greg Gabriel isn't waiting around to cast a few predictions.

"I expect Griffin to put up better numbers in 2012 but that doesn't mean that he will be the better player," Gabriel wrote on "Don't expect either player to have the kind of stats that Cam Newton had last year. I would expect numbers more similar to what Andy Dalton had in Cincinnati."

Dalton's rookie outing netted 3,398 yards and 20 scores alongside just 13 interceptions. That should be considered a successful campaign for Luck, RG3 or any rookie passer, but Newton raised that bar skyward. His 4,051 rookie passing yards shattered Peyton Manning's mark. Cam threw for 21 touchdowns but don't forget he rushed for another 706 yards and 14 scores. Luck is cited as perhaps the top rookie passing prospect of the past 30 years, but who expects him to do what Cam did?

Besides, it's not about personal numbers. When we talk about success for today's quarterbacks, that discussion is invariably linked to where they lead their teams.

"I have no doubt that both players will be excellent NFL quarterbacks," Gabriel wrote, "but it remains to be seen who leads their team to better playoff success. At this time my money would be on Luck and only because of how he has prepared himself for an NFL career."

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content