Ask 5: Who's most underrated QB in college football?

At this point in the fall, most NFL evaluators have finished scouting their primary schools and are now cross-checking certain positions around the country or checking out pop-up players (scouting slang for late-bloomer prospects that emerge during the fall).

With that in mind, I reached out to five executives and asked them this question: Who is the most underrated QB in college football? Here are their answers.

Executive 1: Virginia QB Kurt Benkert
"He has good size, athletic ability and arm strength. He gets the ball out. He's accurate on three levels. Virginia is 5-2 with no real skill-player talent around him."

Executive 2: Oregon QB Justin Herbert
"I'd say Justin Herbert at Oregon. Dude can sling it and the Ducks really fell off after he went down (with an injury)."

Executive 3: Miami QB Malik Rosier
"Rosier has stepped in for (Brad) Kaaya and the team hasn't missed a beat. In fact, his mobility has probably improved them at the position. He shows the arm talent to develop into a next-level prospect with another year under (coach Mark) Richt."

Executive 4: Benkert
"I think Virginia's QB is pretty good. Nobody has been talking about him."

Executive 5: Benkert
"I didn't know much about Benkert before the season. He's been pretty impressive. He makes all of the throws."

Summary: That's three votes for Benkert and one apiece for Herbert and Rosier.

Conclusion: There has been a quiet chatter about Benkert throughout the fall -- our own Chad Reuter identified him as a prospect on the rise after the first month of the season -- and now the buzz is reaching a whole new level.

Herbert is recovering from the fractured collarbone he suffered earlier this season, but I was very impressed with the Ducks QB after meeting him at the Pac-12 media event in the summer. He's huge and he's shown tremendous athleticism as well as arm talent when he's been on the field. I haven't seen much of Rosier, but you can't argue with his results. Miami is currently undefeated and chasing an ACC title. I look forward to digging in and studying these QBs down the road.

Follow Daniel Jeremiah on Twitter @MoveTheSticks.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content


See all the Action

Replay every game all season.