Inside Slant: Marcus Mariota can shatter spread-QB stereotypes

Head coach Mark Helfrich was smarting Sunday from a tough road loss at Michigan State that steepened the climb to a possible College Football Playoff bid for his Oregon team. But if the Ducks coach cracked a smile Sunday, you can bet it happened when he saw the outcome of Marcus Mariota's NFL debut.

Especially given whom it came against.

His ex-quarterback outdueled former Florida State star Jameis Winston in every way in the Tennessee Titans' 42-14 win over the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, a highly anticipated matchup of the 2015 NFL Draft's top two picks.

But more than a duel of top draft picks, it was a duel of stereotypes. Fair or unfair, Winston and Mariota came to personify a pre-draft debate about whether college quarterbacks from spread offenses can make a quick and effective adjustment to pro-style offenses. Winston came from a pro-style system at FSU, and that was no small reason why conventional wisdom came to recognize Winston as the better prospect of the two. Bucs coach Lovie Smith downplayed the system difference in pre-draft remarks about the two, but the club ultimately chose the quarterback thought to be more pro-ready.

The Titans' win was only a snapshot, not nearly enough of a sample for any assumptions to be made about Mariota's career, or Winston's. Their fortunes could be reversed as quickly as Week 2. But Mariota's performance wasn't just good.

And Helfrich is the one who has to sit in the living rooms of top quarterback recruits and answer questions about whether his spread attack is an adequate preparation for the NFL. If he's smart, he'll cite this particular game as evidence to the contrary, and it can be a compelling piece of his sales pitch even if the game doesn't eventually reflect the career arcs of Mariota or Winston.

If nothing else, an impressive rookie season by Mariota should at least shed some light on the fact that not all college spread offenses are the same, nor do they all translate to the pro game in the same way. Multiple NFL scouts have told College Football 24/7 that an Oregon quarterback can make the pro adjustment more easily than one from Baylor, for example, even though both offenses are hurry-up, no-huddle spreads. The reason? The Oregon system requires quarterbacks to read the entire field more, while Baylor and other spreads call for more "half-field reads." Mariota, nevertheless, still must get used to many new things: huddling, playing from under center instead of the shotgun, the mechanics of dropping back, pro terminology and more.

But he breezed through test No. 1 like he'd been doing those things for years. He's not nearly the first spread quarterback to make an NFL living, but if he keeps this up, he could do as much to shatter spread stereotypes as any of them.

Follow Chase Goodbread on Twitter *@ChaseGoodbread*.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content


See all the Action

Replay every game all season.