Picking a favorite accomplishment is tough stuff -- especially on a weekend when he's chasing three NFL records and trying to enter one of the league's most exclusive clubs.
"You're asking me which (one) is the most impressive?" kicker Adam Vinatieri said, laughing. "You're asking me to pick between which car I'd rather have, a Lamborghini or a Ferrari. The answer is yes."
It's not just another game for the only four-time MVP in league history. It could be the most historic day of his remarkable career.
When Manning takes his first snap Sunday against the Tennessee Titans, he will break Gene Upshaw's league record for most consecutive regular-season starts to open a career. The two are tied at 207.
That's just the start.
Beating the Titans would send the Colts into the playoffs for a ninth consecutive year, tying the league record that the Dallas Cowboys set from 1975 to 1983. If Manning throws for 300 yards, he would have 64 career 300-yard games, one more than Dan Marino's NFL record. And if Manning throws three TD passes, he will join Marino and Brett Favre as the third member of the 400-TD club.
Should one of those TD passes go to Manning's favorite receiver, Reggie Wayne would break a tie with Hall of Famer Raymond Berry for second in franchise history. Wayne and Berry each have 68 TD catches.
Not bad for a day's work.
Manning has taken the Colts to the playoffs 10 times in 12 seasons, and just five of his current teammates -- right tackle Ryan Diem, running back Dominic Rhodes, center Jeff Saturday, long snapper Justin Snow and Wayne -- have ever missed the playoffs.
"I think the playoff streak is the most impressive because it's so hard to get there and there are so many variables that can cause you to not get there," Freeney said. "When you have 53 guys on the roster, it becomes a team thing, too, and he's got to get everyone going on the same page."
In 13 NFL seasons, Manning has never missed a start. His streak ranks second only to Favre among NFL quarterbacks. When you count playoff games, Manning has started in 225 consecutive games.
Caldwell, who has coached for more than three decades and was Manning's position coach for seven years, understands how challenging it has been for the quarterback to play every single week.
"Often times people look at the consecutive games played for a quarterback and they look at that like it's supposed to happen that way. But it takes a very, very tough individual to string them together like that," Caldwell said. "That I think is very, very difficult to do. That's quite a feat."
But Manning has a way of making things look routine.
It took Marino 17 seasons to throw for 420 TDs, a number that Manning likely will catch next year -- despite playing three fewer seasons -- and at least one Colts receiver wouldn't mind be paired with his quarterback in the trivia books.
"It would be pretty cool to catch No. 400 and be part of one of the many records he has," Garcon said with a smile.
Manning, as usual, isn't thinking about a milestone game day. He'd rather focus on beating the Titans.
"Every single team we've played all season we've concentrated on that team and that team alone and haven't looked at anything else," he said.
And it's not about to end there.
"I'd say the most impressive would be making the playoffs nine years in a row -- that's if we make the playoffs, we still have to win," Vinatieri said. "I think that just shows such consistency, and that's just something that without a stud quarterback, you probably don't have the possibility of doing. You know he sets new records every week, and when he's done, he'll probably hold every meaningful passing record."
Copyright 2010 by The Associated Press