Readers vote for their most underrated player in NFL


So the powerful wizards behind the NFL's social media accounts asked a simple question on Tuesday: Who is the most underrated player in the NFL?

Vote for the greatest play in NFL history: has picked the 64 best plays ever, and over the next three weeks we are asking fans to cast their votes for the best. Vote now!

The question pairs nicely with Elliot's Harrison's "All-Underrated Team," a squad that makes a lot of sense. Our readers are a different matter. To the results, from 6,586 users on Facebook:

1. Tim Tebow: 15.1%
2. Tony Romo: 13%
3. Von Miller: 7.6%
4. Matt Ryan: 7.1%
5. Russell Wilson: 6.9%
6. Alex Smith: 5.5%
7. Joe Flacco: 5.5%
8. Cam Newton: 4.8%
9. Tom Brady: 4.2%
10. Steven Jackson: 3.9%

Yeah, I'm speechless. The results were so surprising that our crack staff re-checked the results many times. Tim Tebow is a lot of things, but "underrated" as a player is not the first one that comes to mind. My strong guess: Tebow and Romo also would land near the top of many "overrated" lists. (For the record, I like seeing Romo so high. He's been knocked too much. He'd have a lot more playoff success if he played for a different organization.)

Let's go to the Twitter results:

1. Matt Ryan: 30.3%
2. Ben Roethlisberger: 21.9%
3. Sean Lee: 14.8%
4. Tony Romo: 6.9%
5. London Fletcher: 4.7%
6. Cam Newton: 4.0%
7. Stevan Ridley: 3.8%
8. Alex Smith: 3.6%
9. Marques Colston: 3.1%
10. Antonio Cromartie: 2.6%

The lesson, as always: Twitter users are a lot smarter than Facebook users on average. Sean Lee is an inspired choice to be third. Roethlisberger absolutely belongs so high; he didn't even make the Facebook list. Fletcher, Ridley and Colston also were nice choices.

Follow Gregg Rosenthal on Twitter @greggrosenthal.