Fantasy News  

 

2015 fantasy mock draft: Peyton Manning plummets

Print

The Pro Bowl draft will air live on NFL Network tonight at 8 p.m. ET, which inspired us here at NFL Fantasy to do a little drafting of our own. So we grabbed as many of our analysts as possible to put together our second mock draft for the 2015 season. Keep in mind that it's only January and a lot will change during free agency and the 2015 NFL Draft, but this is a good look at our evaluations of various players as the 2014 season comes to a close. The full results and analysis are below.

The standard scoring league consisted of NFL Fantasy LIVE members Adam Rank, Marcas Grant and James Koh, NFL Fantasy writer/editor Alex Gelhar, and NFL Fantasy LIVE senior producer Dylan Milner. Each participant drafted for two teams, as indicated below. Each team needed to assemble a starting lineup of one quarterback, two running backs, two wide receivers, one flex (RB/WR), one tight end, one kicker and one defense/special teams unit.

Draft Order:
1. James Koh Team 1
2. Alex Gelhar Team 1
3. Dylan Milner Team 1
4. Marcas Grant Team 1
5. Adam Rank Team 1
6. James Koh Team 2 
7. Alex Gelhar Team 2
8. Dylan Milner Team 2
9. Marcas Grant Team 2
10. Adam Rank Team 2

Round 1

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
1.
J.K. Team 1 Le'Veon Bell, RB, Pittsburgh Steelers
2.
2.
A.G. Team 1 Matt Forte, RB, Chicago Bears
3.
3.
D.M. Team 1 Eddie Lacy, RB, Green Bay Packers
4.
4.
M.G. Team 1 Jamaal Charles, RB, Kansas City Chiefs
5.
5.
A.R. Team 1 C.J. Anderson, RB, Denver Broncos
6.
6.
J.K. Team 2 Marshawn Lynch, RB, Seattle Seahawks
7.
7.
A.G. Team 2 LeSean McCoy, RB, Philadelphia Eagles
8.
8.
D.M. Team 2 Odell Beckham Jr., WR, New York Giants
9.
9.
M.G. Team 2 Aaron Rodgers, QB, Green Bay Packers
10.
10.
A.R. Team 2 Arian Foster, RB, Houston Texans

ANALYSIS:
Alex Gelhar: A couple of surprises in Round 1, starting with C.J. Anderson jumping into the top five, but the Gary Kubiak hiring could really boost his stock. What'd you think about Milner taking ODB in the first?
Marcas Grant: Too rich for me, but I won't be surprised to see it happen in plenty of real drafts. Arian Foster seems perfect for the bottom of the first round. Plenty of upside when he's healthy. WHEN he's healthy.
A.G.: That's a BIG "when," too. Thus the very necessary CAPS.


Round 2

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
11.
A.R. Team 2 Jeremy Hill, RB, Cincinnati Bengals
2.
12.
M.G. Team 2 DeMarco Murray, RB, Dallas Cowboys
3.
13.
D.M. Team 2 Lamar Miller, RB, Miami Dolphins
4.
14.
A.G. Team 2 Antonio Brown, WR, Pittsburgh Steelers
5.
15.
J.K. Team 2 Andrew Luck, QB, Indianapolis Colts
6.
16.
A.R. Team 1 Jordy Nelson, WR, Green Bay Packers
7.
17.
M.G. Team 1 Dez Bryant, WR, Dallas Cowboys
8.
18.
D.M. Team 1 Alfred Morris, RB, Washington Redskins
9.
19.
A.G. Team 1 Tre Mason, RB, St. Louis Rams
10.
20.
J.K. Team 1 Calvin Johnson, WR, Detroit Lions

ANALYSIS:
M.G.: Remember this time last season when we were all nuts over Giovani Bernard? Now it's Jeremy Hill going at the top of the second round. And what did all of DeMarco Murray's stats get him? A seat behind Hill.
A.G.: Ah, the Gio hype train. I fortunately avoided that fantasy disaster. This time around our drafters were much more concerned with the parity at the RB position, as Lamar Miller, Alfred Morris and Tre Mason all made appearances in Round 2. Somehow I doubt this remains the case come August, you?
M.G.: Mason feels like the most speculative pick right now. But hey, it's January!


Round 3

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
21.
J.K. Team 1 Russell Wilson, QB, Seattle Seahawks
2.
22.
A.G. Team 1 Demaryius Thomas, WR, Denver Broncos
3.
23.
D.M. Team 1 Julio Jones, WR, Atlanta Falcons
4.
24.
M.G. Team 1 T.Y. Hilton, WR, Indianapolis Colts
5.
25.
A.R. Team 1 Alshon Jeffery, WR, Chicago Bears
6.
26.
J.K. Team 2 Jeremy Maclin, WR, Philadelphia Eagles
7.
27.
A.G. Team 2 Rob Gronkowski, TE, New England Patriots
8.
28.
D.M. Team 2 Jimmy Graham, TE, New Orleans Saints
9.
29.
M.G. Team 2 Randall Cobb, WR, Green Bay Packers
10.
30.
A.R. Team 2 A.J. Green, WR, Cincinnati Bengals

ANALYSIS:
A.G.: Perhaps a round late, the run on pass-catchers came in a hurry in Round 3. Nine straight picks were either wide receivers or tight ends. And look, someone still believes in Jimmy Graham!
M.G.: The Graham pick in the third caught me off guard. A.J. Green just barely squeaks into the third round. Methinks that speaks to concern over Andy Dalton, no?
A.G.: The only person not concerned with the Red Rifle (and his supporting cast) in 2015 is that girl from the Wendy's commercials.


Round 4

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
31.
A.R. Team 2 Mike Evans, WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
2.
32.
M.G. Team 2 Carlos Hyde, RB, San Francisco 49ers
3.
33.
D.M. Team 2 DeAndre Hopkins, WR, Houston Texans
4.
34.
A.G. Team 2 Latavius Murray, RB, Oakland Raiders
5.
35.
J.K. Team 2 Justin Forsett, RB, Baltimore Ravens
6.
36.
A.R. Team 1 Joique Bell, RB, Detroit Lions
7.
37.
M.G. Team 1 Rashad Jennings, RB New York Giants
8.
38.
D.M. Team 1 Emmanuel Sanders, WR, Denver Broncos
9.
39.
A.G. Team 1 Brandon Marshall, WR, Chicago Bears
10.
40.
J.K. Team 1 Julius Thomas, TE, Denver Broncos

ANALYSIS:
M.G.: Round 4 is where the shakeup begins. We've been burying Frank Gore for years, but drafting Carlos Hyde this early really feels like we're kicking dirt onto Gore's fantasy grave.
A.G.: Right. But will he Beatrix Kiddo us all and punch his way out once again? That remains to be seen. Just like the fantasy fortunes of most of this bunch, who all seem to carry pretty big "ifs" into the season.
M.G.: Round 4 feels like the make-or-break portion of this draft. "Boom or bust" is written all over it.


Round 5

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
41.
J.K. Team 1 Jerick McKinnon, RB, Minnesota Vikings
2.
42.
A.G. Team 1 Jonathan Stewart, RB, Carolina Panthers
3.
43.
D.M. Team 1 Dan Herron, RB, Indianapolis Colts
4.
44.
M.G. Team 1 Josh Gordon, WR, Cleveland Browns
5.
45.
A.R. Team 1 Andre Ellington, RB, Arizona Cardinals
6.
46.
J.K. Team 2 Kelvin Benjamin, WR, Carolina Panthers
7.
47.
A.G. Team 2 Golden Tate, WR, Detroit Lions
8.
48.
D.M. Team 2 Mark Ingram, RB, New Orleans Saints
9.
49.
M.G. Team 2 Giovani Bernard, RB, Cincinnati Bengals
10.
50.
A.R. Team 2 Sammy Watkins, WR, Buffalo Bills

ANALYSIS:
A.G.: Can we pause for a moment and talk about the three RBs drafted at the top of this round? I'm almost at a loss for words (and I took one of them)!
M.G.: Andre Ellington makes four in the first five slots of this round. And he might be the one I have the most faith in. The running back cliff is steep, my friend.
A.G.: Speaking of cliffs, Josh Gordon in the fifth feels right ... for now. That guy has all-world talent, but his NFL future seems to be hanging in the balance yet again.


Round 6

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
51.
A.R. Team 2 Torrey Smith, WR, Baltimore Ravens
2.
52.
M.G. Team 2 Jordan Matthews, WR, Philadelphia Eagles
3.
53.
D.M. Team 2 Drew Brees, QB, New Orleans Saints
4.
54.
A.G. Team 2 DeSean Jackson, WR, Washington Redskins
5.
55.
J.K. Team 2 Khiry Robinson, RB, New Orleans Saints
6.
56.
A.R. Team 1 Brandin Cooks, WR, New Orleans Saints
7.
57.
M.G. Team 1 Tom Brady, QB, New England Patriots
8.
58.
D.M. Team 1 Martavis Bryant, WR, Pittsburgh Steelers
9.
59.
A.G. Team 1 Julian Edelman, WR, New England Patriots
10.
60.
J.K. Team 1 Michael Floyd, WR, Arizona Cardinals

ANALYSIS:
M.G.: How do you know when Matt "Money" Smith isn't in your draft? Drew Brees lasts until the sixth round. On a side note, I felt a little like I reached for Tom Brady.
A.G.: True, true. You likely could have had Brady a few rounds later, but this to me has the look of a flag-planting round. Rank staked his claim to Cooks (again), Koh to Robinson, Milner to Bryant and me to ... DJax and Edelman?
M.G.: Most of the WRs in this round have obvious flaws ... but plenty of potential. It's like watching "Gotham."


Round 7

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
61.
J.K. Team 1 Isaiah Crowell, RB, Cleveland Browns
2.
62.
A.G. Team 1 Victor Cruz, WR, New York Giants
3.
63.
D.M. Team 1 Coby Fleener, TE, Indianapolis Colts
4.
64.
M.G. Team 1 Dwayne Allen, TE, Indianapolis Colts
5.
65.
A.R. Team 1 Matt Ryan, QB, Atlanta Falcons
6.
66.
J.K. Team 2 LeGarrette Blount, RB, New England Patriots
7.
67.
A.G. Team 2 Bishop Sankey, RB, Tennessee Titans
8.
68.
D.M. Team 2 Doug Martin, RB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
9.
69.
M.G. Team 2 Donte Moncrief, WR, Indianapolis Colts
10.
70.
A.R. Team 2 Melvin Gordon, RB, *rookie*

ANALYSIS:
A.G.: I'm going to dub Round 7 "Daytona Beach" because of all the timeshares we're dealing with here. Who of this round do you trust the most that will likely be splitting carries/targets?
M.G.: Can I say Dwayne Allen? Because I really want to say Dwayne Allen. I still have a fantasy man crush on Dwayne Allen. If not, I'll go with Sankey. Who else will the Titans build around? Zach Mettenberger?
A.G.: Fair point. Could this be the year of Justin Hunter? Who come to think of it, went undrafted. My how the times change. My pick would likely be for Moncrief, because I can't believe the Colts keep throwing to Hakeem Nicks. That's the definition of insanity.


Round 8

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
71.
A.R. Team 2 Devonta Freeman, RB, Atlanta Falcons
2.
72.
M.G. Team 2 Travis Kelce, TE, Kansas City Chiefs
3.
73.
D.M. Team 2 Davante Adams, WR, Green Bay Packers
4.
74.
A.G. Team 2 Kenny Stills, WR, New Orleans Saints
5.
75.
J.K. Team 2 Andre Williams, RB, New York Giants
6.
76.
A.R. Team 1 Greg Olsen, TE, Carolina Panthers
7.
77.
M.G. Team 1 Knile Davis, RB, Kansas City Chiefs
8.
78.
D.M. Team 1 Tony Romo, QB, Dallas Cowboys
9.
79.
A.G. Team 1 Jarvis Landry, WR, Miami Dolphins
10.
80.
J.K. Team 1 Denard Robinson, RB, Jacksonville Jaguars

ANALYSIS:
M.G.: Is there anything that screams "Adam Rank" more than the Melvin Gordon-Devonta Freeman daily double? In fact, I'd have to give this round to Rank for his Freeman and Greg Olsen selections.
A.G.: Agreed. I was rather peeved to see Olsen go a few picks before me. And as much as I love Davante Adams, I feel this might be a tad early for him with guys like Jarvis Landry and Keenan Allen still on the board.
M.G.: The way you feel about Olsen going in this round was how I felt about Adams being drafted. I was hoping he'd fall another round or two.


Round 9

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
81.
J.K. Team 1 Eric Decker, WR, New York Jets
2.
82.
A.G. Team 1 Ben Roethlisberger, QB, Pittsburgh Steelers
3.
83.
D.M. Team 1 Keenan Allen, WR, San Diego Chargers
4.
84.
M.G. Team 1 Robert Turbin, RB, Seattle Seahawks
5.
85.
A.R. Team 1 Terrance West, RB, Cleveland Browns
6.
86.
J.K. Team 2 Terrance Williams, WR, Dallas Cowboys
7.
87.
A.G. Team 2 Cam Newton, QB, Carolina Panthers
8.
88.
D.M. Team 2 C.J. Spiller, RB, Buffalo Bills
9.
89.
M.G. Team 2 Frank Gore, RB, San Francisco 49ers
10.
90.
A.R. Team 2 Philip Rivers, QB, San Diego Chargers

ANALYSIS:
A.G.: After dubbing Round 7 "Daytona Beach," I'll call Round 9 "Panama City Beach" as I believe there are plenty of decisions we will regret here. My Roethlisberger pick included.
M.G.: This does have a Spring Break feel to it. Drafting Terrance Williams or C.J. Spiller is like that shot of tequila. It seems like a good idea at the time, but it won't feel so good later. Whatever. YOLO!
A.G.: 1/21/2015 -- The first and hopefully ONLY use of "YOLO" at NFL Fantasy. But I'll allow it.


Round 10

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
91.
A.R. Team 2 DaVante Parker, WR, *rookie*
2.
92.
M.G. Team 2 Robert Woods, WR, Buffalo Bills
3.
93.
D.M. Team 2 Andre Johnson, WR, Houston Texans
4.
94.
A.G. Team 2 Adrian Peterson, RB, *Commissioner's exempt list*
5.
95.
J.K. Team 2 Christine Michael, RB, Seattle Seahawks
6.
96.
A.R. Team 1 Toby Gerhart, RB, Jacksonville Jaguars
7.
97.
M.G. Team 1 Paul Richardson, WR, Seattle Seahawks
8.
98.
D.M. Team 1 James Starks, RB, Green Bay Packers
9.
99.
A.G. Team 1 Mychal Rivera, TE, Oakland Raiders
10.
100.
J.K. Team 1 Ahmad Bradshaw, RB, Indianapolis Colts

ANALYSIS:
M.G.: Round 10 is all over the place. Adrian Peterson, Toby Gerhart and Paul Richardson? Please try to make some sense of this one for me.
A.G.: Is this the round where we reveal we plotted and executed this mock draft in the span of 1.5 hours? Because this seems to be the most logical time to bring that to light.
M.G.: Dear reader,
We plotted and executed this mock draft in the span of 1.5 hours. Please excuse our rust.


Round 11

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
101.
J.K. Team 1 Seattle Seahawks D/ST
2.
102.
A.G. Team 1 Ryan Tannehill, QB, Miami Dolphins
3.
103.
D.M. Team 1 Vincent Jackson, WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
4.
104.
M.G. Team 1 Alfred Blue, RB, Houston Texans
5.
105.
A.R. Team 1 Ronnie Hillman, RB, Denver Broncos
6.
106.
J.K. Team 2 Philadelphia Eagles D/ST
7.
107.
A.G. Team 2 Todd Gurley, RB, *rookie*
8.
108.
D.M. Team 2 Peyton Manning, QB, Denver Broncos
9.
109.
M.G. Team 2 Amari Cooper, WR, *rookie*
10.
110.
A.R. Team 2 Martellus Bennett, TE, Chicago Bears

ANALYSIS:
A.G.: Here's what I've learned about James Koh in the last year: He has an adorable baby daughter, he loves DeAndre Hopkins and he is a fan of taking defenses early in mock drafts.
M.G.: My summary of Round 11 in two words: Peyton Manning. I know he struggled for the final six weeks of the season, but this feels like a huge overreaction.
A.G.: Oh right, that guy. Yeah, we're probably suffering from a bit of recency bias mixed with a healthy dose of uncertainty. Is Gary Kubiak enough to keep Manning in Denver? Or will the $19 million tip the scales? Time will only tell, and he'll move up draft boards (or off) accordingly.


Round 12

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
111.
A.R. Team 2 Jaelen Strong, WR, *rookie*
2.
112.
M.G. Team 2 Mike Wallace, WR, Miami Dolphins
3.
113.
D.M. Team 2 Joseph Randle, RB, Dallas Cowboys
4.
114.
A.G. Team 2 Roddy White, WR, Atlanta Falcons
5.
115.
J.K. Team 2 Darren Sproles, RB, Philadelphia Eagles
6.
116.
A.R. Team 1 Larry Fitzgerald, WR, Arizona Cardinals
7.
117.
M.G. Team 1 John Brown, WR, Arizona Cardinals
8.
118.
D.M. Team 1 Colin Kaepernick, QB, San Francisco 49ers
9.
119.
A.G. Team 1 Fred Jackson, RB, Buffalo Bills
10.
120.
J.K. Team 1 Matthew Stafford, QB, Detroit Lions

ANALYSIS:
M.G.: On to Round 12, where we went heavy on the old guys. Roddy White, Larry Fitzgerald and Fred Jackson all come off the board. Are any of these guys still impact players?
A.G.: That's a very valid (and somewhat sad) question. I'm the most worried about Fitzgerald given his QB situation and the crop of young WRs waiting in the wings. I think Fred Jackson could surprise people in 2015.
M.G.: Fred Jackson is the new Frank Gore. Who was the new Curtis Martin.


Round 13

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
121.
J.K. Team 1 Stephen Gostkowski, K, New England Patriots
2.
122.
A.G. Team 1 Detroit Lions D/ST
3.
123.
D.M. Team 1 Chris Ivory, RB, New York Jets
4.
124.
M.G. Team 1 Charles Johnson, WR, Minnesota Vikings
5.
125.
A.R. Team 1 Marqise Lee, WR, Jacksonville Jaguars
6.
126.
J.K. Team 2 Kendall Wright, WR, Tennessee Titans
7.
127.
A.G. Team 2 Brandon LaFell, WR, New England Patriots
8.
128.
D.M. Team 2 Anquan Boldin, WR, San Francisco 49ers
9.
129.
M.G. Team 2 Pierre Garcon, WR, Washington Redskins
10.
130.
A.R. Team 2 Kevin White, WR, *rookie*

ANALYSIS:
A.G.: If I could digitally slow clap for you I would, because Charles Johnson is an absolute steal in the 13th round. Well done, sir. Rather than toot your own horn, what other pick did you like?
M.G.: I'll probably be accused of homerism, but I do like the Marqise Lee pick right behind that one. Blake Bortles showed promise last season and that young group of WRs should show improvement.
A.G.: Agreed. Allen Hurns and Allen Robinson will likely be hot names off the waiver wire if they aren't called on draft day.


Round 14

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
131.
A.R. Team 2 Steven Hauschka, K, Seattle Seahawks
2.
132.
M.G. Team 2 Mason Crosby, K, Green Bay Packers
3.
133.
D.M. Team 2 Connor Barth, K, Denver Broncos
4.
134.
A.G. Team 2 Cody Parkey, K, Philadelphia Eagles
5.
135.
J.K. Team 2 Richard Rodgers, TE, Green Bay Packers
6.
136.
A.R. Team 1 Sebastian Janikowski, K, Oakland Raiders
7.
137.
M.G. Team 1 Matt Bryant, K, Atlanta Falcons
8.
138.
D.M. Team 1 Justin Tucker, K, Baltimore Ravens
9.
139.
A.G. Team 1 Ryan Mathews, RB, San Diego Chargers
10.
140.
J.K. Team 1 Andre Holmes, WR, Oakland Raiders

ANALYSIS:
M.G.: Speaking of homers, how about James Koh taking a Cal guy (Richard Rodgers) in a round dominated by kickers? As a Packers fan, I assume you approve.
A.G.: The Packers' tight end position has been more barren than a Wisconsin winter since they lost Jermichael Finley. I don't mind the Rodgers pick as a high-upside flier at the end of the draft.


Round 15

Pick
Overall
Team
Player
1.
141.
J.K. Team 1 Reggie Bush, RB, Detroit Lions
2.
142.
A.G. Team 1 Randy Bullock, K, Houston Texans
3.
143.
D.M. Team 1 Buffalo Bills D/ST
4.
144.
M.G. Team 1 Houston Texans D/ST
5.
145.
A.R. Team 1 New England Patriots D/ST
6.
146.
J.K. Team 2 Dan Carpenter, K, Buffalo Bills
7.
147.
A.G. Team 2 Green Bay Packers D/ST
8.
148.
D.M. Team 2 Baltimore Ravens D/ST
9.
149.
M.G. Team 2 Arizona Cardinals D/ST
10.
150.
A.R. Team 2 St. Louis Rams D/ST

ANALYSIS:
A.G.: So I guess all we have to say about Round 15 is Sir Reginald Alfred Bush? I'll let you get in the final word on this mock draft and your fellow USC alumnus.
M.G.: That would be Sir Reginald Alfred Bush II. And that's about all I have to say about that.


Print