"I get the notification via e-mail, which I thought was some kind of crazy scam," he recalled. "I was like, you won the Nigerian lottery in Malaysia, that sort of thing. I was about to dismiss it, then I started reading a little bit more into it: Hey, this seems to be legit."
Predict the pick
When Herrera went to his banker in Honolulu to have some contest forms notarized, she was sure it was a fraud. They spent nearly two hours researching the companies involved, even calling the Better Business Bureau. Finally, the bank's vice president came over with the verdict: It was for real.
It was all very real Friday when Herrera, 34, sat at a desk in midtown Manhattan and had retired New York Giants defensive end Michael Strahan yell at him in front of a video crew. Herrera beat out 31 other finalists last month in a promotion sponsored by Monster.com and the NFL to become the league's "Director of Fandemonium."
One problem: Herrera won this contest because he's such a knowledgeable, passionate football fan. What if he looks down at the card and immediately thinks, "That's a terrible pick!"
"I don't want to do that on national TV," he said, promising to be professional. "I'll try to work up as much enthusiasm as possible no matter who they pick."
So how did a guy growing up in Hawaii become a Vikings fan? With no local franchise to root for, Herrera explained, kids pick a team either because they like the style of play or have relatives living in the city.
Well, Herrera doesn't have any family in Minneapolis.
"I liked those big horn helmets and stuff. I thought that was cool," he said. "When I was kid, I was like, 'OK, I'm going to be a Viking.' Just to be different from everybody else."
"I've never even been close to the wonderful state of Minnesota," Herrera said. "But now that I've won, I now have the money to do it."
Mock draft central
Find out how NFL.com and NFL Network experts think the first round will unfold by checking out their mock drafts. Get a look at all the picks. More ...
A self-described failed kicker, Herrera last played football as a high school freshman, when he was cut by the junior varsity team after accidentally hitting the quarterback in the head. The only team he competed with after that was in the academic bowl.
These days, Herrera takes on a friend in the digital realm. They'll each form a roster of a franchise's all-time great players, then see which would win by running a computer simulation.
Herrera learned about the NFL contest when he saw an ad during the Super Bowl. He rushed to his computer to fill out an entry, then didn't think much about it until he received that e-mail in early March. He flew to New York later that month for a two-day final that included trivia questions, coin-flip contests and interviews.
Herrera looked right at home recording a video with Strahan on Friday. In fact, it was the TV star/former player who kept flubbing his lines, not the short Homeland Security employee. The Big Apple certainly isn't intimidating to Herrera -- he attended New York University.
And Herrera already seems adept at fending off media inquiries. Asked about his job, Herrera mentioned the agency, then added, "That's as much as I can say.
"That's as far as I'll go," he said. "My boss will kill me."
Copyright 2009 by The Associated Press