Skip to main content

NFL Summer Games, edge rusher: Von Miller terrorizes QBs

American football isn't an Olympic sport -- yet. But with the world's best athletes set to compete in the 2016 Olympics in Rio, we thought we'd get in on the fun by holding a medal competition at nine key positions. NFL Media analysts ranked the top three players at each spot, with points assigned accordingly -- three points for each first-place ranking, two for each second-place ranking and one for each third-place ranking. The points were totaled, resulting in final gold-, silver- and bronze-medal finishers. Below, you'll find the results -- and each analyst's individual ballot -- at edge rusher.

The Edge Rusher Podium

GOLD MEDAL:Von Miller, Denver Broncos (44 total points)

SILVER MEDAL:J.J. Watt, Houston Texans (37)

BRONZE MEDAL:Khalil Mack, Oakland Raiders (32)

Analyst Ballots

Gil Brandt: 1) Khalil Mack 2) Justin Houston 3) Von Miller

Mack developed at an off-the-charts rate in Year 2, collecting 15 sacks. The addition of Bruce Irvin in Oakland should only help him. To truly appreciate how big Houston is and how well he moves for a man of his size, one has to see the Chiefs OLB in person. Miller, who's been a force since arriving in Denver as the second overall pick in 2011, helped guide the Broncos to a title with an unbelievable postseason. The scary thing? He can be even better going forward.

Willie McGinest: 1) Von Miller 2) J.J. Watt 3) Khalil Mack

Miller's impact is felt on nearly every snap. He's an elite pass rusher, and that was very evident all through the playoffs and the Super Bowl. Watt is very strong, athletic and explosive, and with his energy, the guy is one of the toughest in the game. Mack has speed and strength on his side, which helped him earn All-Pro nods at two positions.

Gregg Rosenthal: 1) Von Miller 2) Khalil Mack 3) Justin Houston

Miller has been the most consistent pure pass rusher since the day he entered the league. His run defense is also underrated, although Mack's complete game could lift him above Miller before long.

Charley Casserly: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Khalil Mack 3) Von Miller

J.J. Watt is the best outside and inside pass rusher in the game. Mack hit his stride in his second year and will only get better. Miller has been a consistent performer since he came into the NFL.

Nate Burleson: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Von Miller 3) Ezekiel Ansah

Watt's engine matches his athleticism, work ethic and everything else he does on the football field. Everything a player can do on Madden, Miller can do in real life. Ansah has so much raw talent, and his best days are ahead of him.

Elliot Harrison: 1) Von Miller 2) Justin Houston 3) Khalil Mack

As much as it would be nice to move Khalil Mack up, Justin Houston has earned a silver nod. Let us not forget the man put up 22 sacks when healthy in 2014. That's how we are going to leave it for now, anyway. Von Miller might let success go to his head. He might take forever to get in uniform with this contract stuff. But any player who plays the way he did in the most important games of his life should win the gold.

Michael Robinson: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Khalil Mack 3) Von Miller

Watt's versatility and explosiveness have made him the best defensive player in the league. Mack is still learning the game and has great potential to improve off his 15-sack sophomore season. Miller is arguably the most valuable linebacker in the game, proving his significance in the Broncos' playoff run.

Marcas Grant: 1) Von Miller 2) Khalil Mack 3) Clay Matthews

Miller's play set the tone in Super Bowl 50 -- a reminder of how dominant he's been during his NFL career. Matthews takes a back seat to Mack after being asked to play more middle linebacker the past two seasons, but both are great at terrorizing quarterbacks.

Shaun O'Hara: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Von Miller 3) Khalil Mack

Watt is still the most dominant defensive player -- he affects plays in so many ways. Miller single-handedly won the Super Bowl. As far as OLB/DE guys are concerned, nobody plays the run and pass as well and as powerfully as Mack does.

Bucky Brooks: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Von Miller 3) Khalil Mack

Say what you will about Watt's WWE-like persona, but there's no disputing the effectiveness of his workmanlike game. He has dominated the league as a premier pass rusher exhibiting extraordinary strength, power and hand skills. With the freedom to align anywhere on the front to attack the most vulnerable pass protector, he will remain a top sack producer for the next few years.

Conor Orr: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Khalil Mack 3) Von Miller

By 2018, Khalil Mack will be the best defensive player in football -- and it won't even be close.

Solomon Wilcots: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Von Miller 3) Khalil Mack

Watt is -- hands down -- the winner of this category, as everyone else is fighting for silver. Miller has been a disruptive force since he joined the league in 2011 and proved that in last season's playoffs. Mack is devastating to his opponents -- the sky is the limit for this guy.

Dave Dameshek: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Von Miller 3) Ziggy Ansah

You know plenty about the first two guys, but look out for Ansah. The talented "project" is already great -- and he still has room to improve.

Ike Taylor: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Von Miller 3) Khalil Mack

Having at least 17.5 sacks in three of the last four seasons solidifies Watt's spot at the top. Miller and Mack are elite at their positions, but because Watt is in the league, everybody else is fighting for silver.

Alex Gelhar: 1) Von Miller 2) Khalil Mack 3) Justin Houston

No one has a better first step than Miller, while Mack is an all-around force to be reckoned with. Houston is coming off ACL surgery -- but when healthy, he's a truly elite pass rusher.

Brian Baldinger: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Von Miller 3) Khalil Mack

Watt's sack numbers are unlike any other right now. All three of these players are difficult to stop because they are complete packages.

Kevin Patra: 1) Khalil Mack 2) Von Miller 3) Michael Bennett

One day, we will fondly remember 2016 as "The Year of the Mack."

Eric Davis: 1) Von Miller 2) J.J. Watt 3) Michael Bennett

Miller is the best because of one thing: He creates turnovers. Watt is elite and his numbers support that. Bennett is as disruptive as Miller and Watt, and he's been one of the best players on a very good defense. He deserves to be mentioned here.

Jamie Dukes: 1) Von Miller 2) Khalil Mack 3) Muhammad Wilkerson

Von Miller is #SuperBowl. Mack is so explosive, and Wilkerson needs to get credit for what he does.

Adam Rank: 1) J.J. Watt 2) Khalil Mack 3) Von Miller

Well, the hipster in me wanted to make Mack the gold-medal winner, but I just couldn't do it. I wanted to because you know the Raiders would have had my back on Twitter, but there is no shame in the silver here. Watt is the very best at his position. I'd have him and Gronk as the two best players in the game. AB and Brady are also in the mix, but nobody stands up to Watt just yet.

I know it might be a mild upset to have Miller as the bronze winner. But take a look at his entire 2015 season. He was truly great in the Super Bowl and playoffs, while his overall season was ... good. Would you rather have Mack or Miller in 2016? Don't kid yourself.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content