McElroy ended that drought. His reward will be a seat on the bench.
Sanchez, Tebow and most of the Jets starters didn't play in this battle between backups and guys fighting for roster spots.
Trent Edwards threw for 197 yards and two TDs to help the Eagles (4-0) finish unbeaten in the preseason for the first time since 1995.
None of that will matter when the games count.
Lurie said the team must make a "substantial improvement" for Reid to return for his 15th season next year. He added another 8-8 record would be "unacceptable."
"I don't have a level or anything like that," Lurie said. "I want to be clear about that. You try to make the best judgment you can after the season."
Reid's contract runs through 2013.
"I don't care about that stuff," Reid said. "He has high expectations. I have high expectations. Let's go play. We surely won't be satisfied with 8-8. We're striving for better than that. I'm not worried about it. I understand the business. I have a great relationship with Jeffrey."
McElroy finished 12 of 17 for 90 yards and one TD. He also rushed for 33 yards.
"Obviously we went out there with the intention and the hope to score some touchdowns, so we were able to get one," McElroy said. "The execution was great. I told the guys when we were out on the field, I said: `Hey, let's just make the most of this opportunity, you don't get down here very often, let's not take it for granted, let's punch it in."'
A seventh-round draft pick out of Alabama last year, McElroy spent his rookie season on injured reserve after dislocating his right thumb while playing against Philadelphia last preseason.
"That was obviously a point of emphasis for us, was just red-area execution, and we were able to do it for at least that one drive," McElroy said.
Sanchez was 24 of 35 (68.6 percent) for 203 yards with two interceptions and six sacks. Tebow completed 36.1 percent (13 for 36) of his passes for 151 yards with two interceptions and seven sacks.
Despite Tebowmania, there's no controversy in New York. Sanchez is the clear-cut starter, but the way the Jets use Tebow will be intensely scrutinized.
McElroy guided the offense on a 14-play, 77-yard drive that consumed 8:04 to put the Jets up 7-0. He scrambled for a first down on fourth-and-1 to keep the drive going.
Edwards, a veteran and former starter in Buffalo, is competing for a roster spot with Mike Kafka, who began training camp as the backup to Vick.
He'll surely land a home if he gets cut.
"I want to be here," Edwards said. "This is the team I want to play for. I feel I can help these guys."
The Eagles failed to live up to enormous expectations last year and needed a four-game winning streak to close out the season at .500.
"You just got to make the best decisions you can after the season," Lurie said. "As I said, 8-8 was unacceptable. Yeah, I guess, if two-thirds of the team is not playing, there's always exceptions."
Lurie spoke to reporters for nearly 40 minutes in his annual state of the team address. It was originally scheduled for Aug. 5, but was canceled because Garrett Reid, oldest son of Andy, died that day.
Notes: The Eagles beat the Jets 45-19 last December. Philadelphia entered that game at 5-8 while New York was 8-5. ... Jets DE Quinton Coples had a sack in each preseason game and finished with 4 1/2. ... Newly acquired RT Jason Smith entered the game for the Jets in the second quarter. Smith, the No. 2 overall pick in 2009, was acquired from St. Louis to back up Austin Howard. ... Eagles rookie DE Vinny Curry had two sacks.
Copyright 2012 by The Associated Press