Coaches highly skeptical of Schiano hiring at Senior Bowl

MOBILE, Ala. -- The Senior Bowl isn't just about scouting top college prospects. It also serves as an unofficial coaches convention and a place where unemployed coaches come to find work.

The news of Greg Schiano becoming head coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers not only surprised many of the coaches I spoke with today, but it downright depressed a few seasoned NFL men waiting in line for their chance to become a head coach.

Smith: Judging recent hires

After a flurry of new hires around the NFL, Jason Smith breaks down the good, the bad and the mind-boggling. More ...

Here are some of the statements I gathered from coaches in the hotel lobby, on the condition of anonymity:

» "Good for Greg, but what does it say about the Bucs' vision for the future? A college guy with a .500 record and no real NFL experience ..."

» "If Tampa thinks they're getting another Jim Harbaugh, think again. Greg is a good coach, but Harbaugh played QB in the NFL for 15 years, worked under Norv Turner in Oakland and his brother is an NFL coach."

» A third coach just shook his head and said: "Here we go again thinking a college guy who relates to 18-year-olds can handle the 30-year-old guys, understand the salary cap and go toe-to-toe with the likes of [Bill] Belichick, [Tom] Coughlin and [Mike] McCarthy."

» Finally one coach added: "He better get two NFL coordinators with former head-coaching experience if he wants to compete with New Orleans, Atlanta and Carolina."

Schiano has a fine general manager to work with in Mark Dominik and a terrific young quarterback in Josh Freeman. I just hope he can make a quick transition from the Big East to the NFL.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content


See all the Action

Replay every game all season.