Photo Essays  

 

Published: April 30, 2013 at 06:19 p.m.
Updated: May 2, 2013 at 10:36 p.m.

Worst NFL draft picks by team

For the 2013 NFL Draft, NFL.com writers selected their best and worst picks for all 32 teams. Then, we allowed users to choose their best and worst. Here's the list of the worst draft picks for each team.

32 Photos Total

  • Kansas City Chiefs - Todd Blackledge (53 percent) 32

    Paul Spinelli/Associated Press

    Kansas City Chiefs - Todd Blackledge (53 percent)

    Pretty much every quarterback not named John Elway, Dan Marino or Jim Kelly selected in the first round of the 1983 NFL Draft will make it on this list. Have the Chiefs ever recovered from this?

  • Jacksonville Jaguars - Blaine Gabbert (33 percent) 31

    Patric Schneider/Associated Press

    Jacksonville Jaguars - Blaine Gabbert (33 percent)

    The fans have already given up on Gabbert, who was the No. 10 overall selection in 2011. Well, it's hard to blame them.

  • Oakland Raiders - JaMarcus Russell (92 percent) 30

    Greg Trott/Associated Press

    Oakland Raiders - JaMarcus Russell (92 percent)

    Is anybody else surprised Russell received just 92 percent of the vote? I mean, Marc Wilson was bad, but Russell was one of the two worst picks in NFL history (looking at you, Ryan Leaf).

  • Philadelphia Eagles - Freddie Mitchell (39 percent) 29

    G. Newman Lowrance/Associated Press

    Philadelphia Eagles - Freddie Mitchell (39 percent)

    The Eagles' search for a wide receiver seemingly spanned decades and they certainly missed with this first-round selection.

  • Detroit Lions - Charles Rogers (50 percent) 28

    Duane Burleson/Associated Press

    Detroit Lions - Charles Rogers (50 percent)

    You figured a player during the Matt Millen era was going to be selected. And then you figured it was going to be a receiver because you had so many to choose from. Rogers was the correct choice.

  • Cleveland Browns - Tim Couch (43 percent) 27

    Roberto Borea/Associated Press

    Cleveland Browns - Tim Couch (43 percent)

    If Browns fans want to lament about what could have been with Donovan McNabb, please stop. The Browns were down to two quarterbacks -- Couch and Akili Smith. So it wasn't going to end well.

  • Buffalo Bills - J.P. Losman (33 percent) 26

    Jason Babyak/Associated Press

    Buffalo Bills - J.P. Losman (33 percent)

    Jonathan Paul had promise, but like the team's uniforms of his era, he needs to be put out of the minds of Bills fans.

  • Arizona Cardinals - Andre Wadsworth (36 percent) 25

    Mark J. Rebilas/USA TODAY Sports

    Arizona Cardinals - Andre Wadsworth (36 percent)

    I thought Bryant Johnson (16 percent) was a worse choice for the Birds, but the fans tabbed Wadsworth. Not that he wasn't an awful choice, because he certainly was.

  • New York Jets - Vernon Gholston (55 percent) 24

    Paul Spinelli/Associated Press

    New York Jets - Vernon Gholston (55 percent)

    Jets fans certainly had their pick of the litter and it's hard to figure somebody could carry more than 50 percent of the vote. But that's how badly the Jets fans feel about Gholston.

  • Tennessee Titans - Pacman Jones (54 percent) 23

    Mark Humphrey/Associated Press

    Tennessee Titans - Pacman Jones (54 percent)

    This was a no-doubter as Jones secured higher than 50 percent of the vote.

  • San Diego Chargers - Ryan Leaf (98 percent) 22

    Al Golub/Associated Press

    San Diego Chargers - Ryan Leaf (98 percent)

    The two percent who didn't vote for Leaf were merely being contrarians. Especially since Leaf earned the six spots on this countdown.

  • Miami Dolphins - Ted Ginn Jr. (54 percent) 21

    Hans Deryk/Associated Press

    Miami Dolphins - Ted Ginn Jr. (54 percent)

    There were some other deserving candidates, that's for sure. But the fans did a great job with Ginn.�

  • Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Bo Jackson (59 percent) 20

    Kevin Reece/Associated Press

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Bo Jackson (59 percent)

    While he was the best possible draft choice in Raiders history according to the fans (seriously), he was the worst possible choice for the Bucs.

  • Carolina Panthers - Kerry Collins (32 percent) 19

    David Stluka / STLUD

    Carolina Panthers - Kerry Collins (32 percent)

    Collins led the Panthers to the 1996 NFC Championship Game in his second year, but still gets the nod over Dwayne Jarrett.

  • St. Louis Rams - Lawrence Phillips (30 percent) 18

    Greg Trott/Associated Press

    St. Louis Rams - Lawrence Phillips (30 percent)

    To be fair, not drafting RG3 captured the most votes (41 percent) but for guys actually in uniform, Phillips takes the prize.

  • New Orleans Saints - Ricky Williams (43 percent) 17

    Judi Bottini/Associated Press

    New Orleans Saints - Ricky Williams (43 percent)

    The Saints surrendered their entire draft for the right to select Williams.

  • Dallas Cowboys - Shante Carver (28 percent) 16

    National Football League

    Dallas Cowboys - Shante Carver (28 percent)

    The Cowboys have some questionable picks over their illustrious history, but Carver was voted as the club's worst.

  • Pittsburgh Steelers - 2008 draft class (50 percent) 15

    Ben Liebenberg/NFL

    Pittsburgh Steelers - 2008 draft class (50 percent)

    The Steelers have drafted well in their history, but the 2008 class was the exception which proves the rule.

  • Chicago Bears - Cade McNown (54 percent) 14

    David Stluka/Associated Press

    Chicago Bears - Cade McNown (54 percent)

    The class of 1999 had a lot of misses at quarterback, but McNown stands out for Bears fans.

  • New York Giants - Ron Dayne (36 percent) 13

    David Stluka/Associated Press

    New York Giants - Ron Dayne (36 percent)

    Dayne was a standout college player, but never produced in the NFL and is recognized by Giants fans as the worst draft pick in team history.

  • Cincinnati Bengals - Akili Smith (36 percent) 12

    Don Heupel/Associated Press

    Cincinnati Bengals - Akili Smith (36 percent)

    The Bengals have missed on a ton of quarterbacks in their history, but Smith stands out as the worst.

  • Washington Redskins - 1992 and 1993 draft classes (37 percent) 11

    Alix Drawec/NFL

    Washington Redskins - 1992 and 1993 draft classes (37 percent)

    Heath Shuler was bad, but the fans voted for the entire 1992 and 1993 draft picks.

  • Indianapolis Colts - John Elway (45 percent) 10

    Paul Sakuma/Associated Press

    Indianapolis Colts - John Elway (45 percent)

    Elway never played a down for the Colts, and thus he is considered the worst pick in club history.

  • Minnesota Vikings - Troy Williamson (57 percent) 9

    David Stluka/Associated Press

    Minnesota Vikings - Troy Williamson (57 percent)

    Williamson was thought to be the next Randy Moss. He wasn't and the fans here let him know about it.

  • Green Bay Packers - Tony Mandarich (69 percent) 8

    Alan Greth/Associated Press

    Green Bay Packers - Tony Mandarich (69 percent)

    When four out of the first five picks in the 1989 NFL Draft go to the Hall of Fame, the guy who doesn't sure stands out.

  • Seattle Seahawks - Aaron Curry (47 percent) 7

    Paul Jasienski/Associated Press

    Seattle Seahawks - Aaron Curry (47 percent)

    Curry was considered the most can't-miss prospect in the 2009 NFL Draft. But he missed.

  • Denver Broncos - Tim Tebow (47 percent) 6

    Eric Lars Bakke/Associated Press

    Denver Broncos - Tim Tebow (47 percent)

    Tebow has won more playoff games in Denver than Peyton Manning, but the fans say he was the worst pick in franchise history.

  • Houston Texans - David Carr (60 percent) 5

    National Football League

    Houston Texans - David Carr (60 percent)

    Carr was the first draft pick in club history, and he was also the worst according to the fans.

  • Atlanta Falcons - Aundray Bruce (45 percent) 4

    National Football League

    Atlanta Falcons - Aundray Bruce (45 percent)

    Bruce was the first overall selection in the 1988 NFL Draft, and also No. 1 as worst pick in Falcons history.

  • New England Patriots - Ken Sims (39 percent) 3

    Paul Spinelli/Associated Press

    New England Patriots - Ken Sims (39 percent)

    The Patriots missed on the No. 1 overall pick in the 1982 NFL Draft.

  • San Francisco 49ers - Gio Carmazzi (45 percent) 2

    Paul Sakuma/Associated Press

    San Francisco 49ers - Gio Carmazzi (45 percent)

    Carmazzi went four rounds in front of Brady in the 2000 NFL Draft.

  • Baltimore Ravens - Kyle Boller (62 percent) 1

    Stephan Savoia/Associated Press

    Baltimore Ravens - Kyle Boller (62 percent)

    The quarterback-starved Ravens missed out with this pick, and the team's fans said it was their worst pick ever.

Discuss ()

NFL News
CONTENT
15