CFB 24/7  


Ask 5: Which college coach would make best NFL coach?

Chip Kelly will make his much-anticipated NFL coaching debut on Monday night when his Philadelphia Eagles square off against the Washington Redskins. Kelly was wildly successful at the University of Oregon, and the NFL world is very intrigued by his fast-paced offensive system.

In a weekly series, draft analyst Daniel Jeremiah polls five NFL personnel executives about college football's top prospects.

» What prospect has most to prove before draft?
» What NFL player does Mosley remind you of?
» Clowney's decline minor or major issue?
» Which position will be deepest in 2014 draft?
» Who is most improved player this season?
» Who is best prospect from non-BCS school?
» Which NFL assistant could be best college coach?
» Who's better: Murray or Mettenberger?
» Who are most surprising NFL rookies?
» Who's better, Luke Joeckel or Jake Matthews?
» Which college coach is best fit for NFL?
» Is zone-read offense here to stay in the NFL?
» More valuable: Dominant corner or safety?
» Is Clowney top defensive prospect in last decade?
» Better player, Dion Jordan or Anthony Barr?
» Does Johnny Manziel's game translate to NFL?

If Kelly is able to duplicate the early NFL success of another former Pac-10/Pac-12 head coach, Jim Harbaugh, it will be open season on college coaches when NFL hiring season rolls around. With that in mind, I polled five NFL executives this week and asked them which college coach would make the best NFL head coach. Here are their answers:

Executive No. 1: Notre Dame's Brian Kelly

"Kelly has won in three challenging turnaround jobs -- Central Michigan, Cincinnati and Notre Dame. He has a very good understanding of offensive matchups and he's shown a good feel for evaluating personnel."

Executive No. 2: Boise State's Chris Petersen

"He's smart and very organized. He has good personnel, but his team always plays above its talent level. Also, he's just a very good man. Very humble."

Executive No. 3: Penn State's Bill O'Brien

"He's been a successful NFL coordinator, and he has the temperament, leadership and character you're looking for in a head coach."

Executive No. 4: Texas A&M's Kevin Sumlin

"I'm a big fan of Kevin Sumlin. He has a great personality. He has a natural charisma about him, and he is outstanding dealing with the players, media and fans. He has all of the qualities I'd want in an NFL head coach."

Billick: A change of pace in the NFL?
While Chip Kelly's Eagles are sure to push the tempo, Brian Billick doesn't anticipate a football revolution. More ...

Executive No. 5: Sumlin

"He has the perfect demeanor for a head coach. He knows the pulse of his team. He makes football fun for his players, but he can also be a hard ass. He runs a great practice. The tempo is excellent."


Two votes for Sumlin, one each for O'Brien, Petersen and Kelly.

Conclusion: There is plenty of coaching talent at the collegiate level and NFL executives are excited about several of them. Sumlin was the only coach to get more than one vote. He's come under some recent criticism for his handling of Johnny Manziel, but that wasn't a concern for any of these five executives.

A few of the personnel men I polled had a difficult time deciding on just one coach. A few of the other names that popped up in our discussions: Stanford's David Shaw, Miami's Al Golden, Alabama's Nick Saban and Ohio State's Urban Meyer.

Follow Daniel Jeremiah on Twitter @MoveTheSticks.


The previous element was an advertisement.

NFL Shop

NFL News