Free agency primer: Ranking the cornerbacks


Around the League's positional free-agent previews are ranked according to the players we would want -- not the players who will make the most money. We've covered top pass rushers, interior linemenrunning backs, wide receivers and the top-85 players overall. Now our series continues with available cornerbacks. We listed each player with the team they played for in 2012. Here goes:

Solid starters

1. Brent Grimes, Atlanta Falcons
2. Sean Smith, Miami Dolphins (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Kansas City Chiefs)
3. Aqib Talib, New England Patriots (UPDATE: Agreed to deal with the New England Patriots.)
4. Chris Houston, Detroit Lions (UPDATE: Agreed to re-sign with the Detroit Lions)
5. Antoine Winfield, Minnesota Vikings
6. Keenan Lewis, Pittsburgh Steelers (UPDATE: Signed with the New Orleans Saints)

Notes: Let's start with Smith. He's been widely touted as the top corner on the market, but I can't get past his inconsistent play. Smith is big and physical and will draw interest, but whatever team lands him must find a way to pull more steady week-to-week play out of the four-year pro. Grimes was lost to an Achilles' injury in the season opener, but Falcons coach Mike Smith said his recovery has been "outstanding." With Atlanta hoping to re-sign safety William Moore, Grimes might escape on the open market. Possible fit? How about the Patriots. They don't overspend on free agents and Grimes looms as a bargain post-injury. The prospect of grabbing this legitimate starting corner on the cheap makes him my No. 1.

New England must decide what to do with Talib, who was uneven last season. Pro Football Focus points out Talib allowed a whopping 775 yards on 592 snaps. Still, when he was lost to injury against the Baltimore Ravens in the playoffs, the Patriots suffered. Lewis matured last season in Pittsburgh. He led the NFL with 16 passes defended and improved in coverage as the campaign progressed. In this group, only Smith played more snaps (1,068) than Lewis (943).

Released by the Vikings, Winfield is extremely versatile. He's a year-to-year player, but remains a quality starter.

Starters with questions

7. Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, Philadelphia Eagles (UPDATE: Rodgers-Cromartie and the Denver Broncos agreed to a one-year deal on Wednesday night, according to's Ian Rapoport.
8. Nnamdi Asomugha, Philadelphia Eagles
9. Bradley Fletcher, St. Louis Rams (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Philadelphia Eagles)
10. Derek Cox, Jacksonville Jaguars (UPDATE: Cox agreed to a four-year congtract with the San Diego Chargers late Wednesday, U-T San Diego reported).
11. Cary Williams, Baltimore Ravens (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Philadelphia Eagles)
12. Dunta Robinson, Atlanta Falcons (UPDATE: Signed with the Kansas City Chiefs)
13. Greg Toler, Arizona Cardinals (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Indianapolis Colts)

Notes: Rodgers-Cromartie might be the most naturally talented of the bunch, but his play was downright baffling at times in 2012. His physical gifts are abundant, but Rodgers-Cromartie struggled against the run in Philly's confused secondary. He'll find work, but at 26, DRC's already been dumped by two teams. Fletcher is a potential bargain for the right team, but a handful of strong outings were diminished by a devastating penalties and durability issues in 2012.

With the offseason officially under way, Around the League will examine what's next for all 32 teams.

AFC East
» Bills | Dolphins | Jets | Patriots
AFC North
» Bengals | Browns | Ravens | Steelers
AFC South
» Colts | Jaguars | Texans | Titans
AFC West
» Broncos | Chargers | Chiefs | Raiders
NFC East
» Cowboys | Eagles | Giants | Redskins
NFC North
» Bears | Lions | Packers | Vikings
NFC South
» Buccaneers | Falcons | Panthers | Saints
NFC West
» Cardinals | Niners | Rams | Seahawks

The Jaguars reportedly wanted Derek Cox back next season, but injuries have prevented him from playing a full 16 games since 2009. He's been a reliable corner when healthy. Williams won't re-sign with the Ravens. The Colts make sense as a potential suitor considering Chuck Pagano knows Williams well. He'll likely be overpaid for a corner who was burned too often in Baltimore. Toler is intriguing. He doesn't have many starts, but his aggressive play turned heads. The Cardinals have shown interest in bringing him back.

Productive in right system

14. Adam Jones, Cincinnati Bengals
15. DeAngelo Hall, Washington Redskins
16. E.J. Biggers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
17. Antoine Cason, San Diego Chargers
18. Kyle Arrington, New England Patriots
19. Mike Jenkins, Dallas Cowboys
20. Tracy Porter, Denver Broncos

Notes: Jones pumped out a strong season in Cincinnati. The corner-formerly-known-as-Pacman played in all 16 games for the first time in his career, but I'd be wary of him going elsewhere. Mike Zimmer made the most of him and the Bengals are a candidate to re-sign him. Biggers started 12 games for Tampa. After the Giants dismantled Biggers in Week 2, he ultimately took Talib's place in the lineup and improved down the stretch. The 6-foot-1 Cason is a bigger corner who started 16 games for the Chargers last season and is seen as a potential option for coordinator Todd Bowles in Arizona.

After an NFL-leading seven picks in 2011, Arrington was a productive slot corner in 2012. He isn't the top priority in New England, but Arrington's agent reportedly talked shop with the Patriots at the combine. Jenkins is an often-baffling performer who lost his starting role in Dallas. The former first-round pick is now just another name destined for dime coverage. Porter was a disappointment in Denver, starting just four games after suffering a seizure in August. Once healthy, he had trouble winning playing time.

Supporting cast

21. Jerraud Powers, Indianapolis Colts (UPDATE: Signed with the Arizona Cardinals)
22. Quentin Jammer, San Diego Chargers
23. Captain Munnerlyn, Carolina Panthers
24. Aaron Ross, Jacksonville Jaguars (UPDATE: Signed with the New York Giants)
25. Jacob Lacey, Detroit Lions
26. Stanford Routt, Houston Texans
27. Chris Owens, Atlanta Falcons
28. Sheldon Brown, Cleveland Browns
29. Terence Newman, Cincinnati Bengals
30. Joselio Hanson, Oakland Raiders
31. William Middleton, Jacksonville Jaguars
32. Rashean Mathis, Jacksonville Jaguars
33. Marcus Trufant, Seattle Seahawks
34. Darius Butler, Indianapolis Colts (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Indianapolis Colts)
35. Drayton Florence, Detroit Lions (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Carolina Panthers)
36. Brice McCain, Houston Texans
37. Ryan Mouton, Tennessee Titans
38. Shawntae Spencer, Oakland Raiders
39. Terrence McGee, Buffalo Bills
40. Kelvin Hayden, Chicago Bears
41. Brandon McDonald, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
42. Chris Carr, San Diego Chargers
43. Cedric Griffin, Washington Redskins
44. Alan Ball, Houston Texans
45. D.J. Moore, Chicago Bears
46. Will Allen, New England Patriots

Notes: Powers has underwhelmed as a starter, but might loom as an option for coordinator John Pagano in San Diego, where Jammer -- at 33 -- has played his last game. You'd think the Panthers would like Munnerlyn back, but the cap-strapped franchise might not be able to re-sign him. McKelvin brings value in the return game and Bills general manager Buddy Nix expressed interest last month in re-signing him. McKelvin might bolt because wants to play more defense in 2013. Routt is a former second-round pick who was cut by the Chiefs last season, wound up in Houston and might be running out of chances.

Rosenthal: Top 85 free agents
This year's free-agent crop lacks star power, but provides immense depth. Gregg Rosenthal ranks available players. More...

Sheldon Brown is on the wrong side of 30, but was a mostly reliable presence for Cleveland, but he won't beat out younger, more athletic corners. Tampa might be a fit. Like Adam Jones, Newman put in good work for the Bengals last season, but this aging corner doesn't have much of a market. Hanson is essentially a slot corner.

Position Overview

There's no grand prize here, but that changes if Darrelle Revis is ultimately shopped by the Jets.

This group is deep. No shutdown corners, but plenty of younger, 20-somethings ready to contribute. Teams should avoid overpaying for the top of the list, where there's not enough to distinguish one player from the next. Someone's going to make Sean Smith rich. Cary Williams, too. But the better value addition might be a younger player like Toler.

Expect a handful of these guys to test the market before re-signing with their current teams. You can't have enough corners in this league. With three- and four-wideout sets becoming the norm, reserve defensive backs have never been more important.

Teams with a need

Carolina Panthers: With Chris Gamble and Munnerlyn potentially on the outs, it's time to restock.
Cincinnati Bengals: Terence Newman and Adam Jones aren't getting any younger -- and they might wind up elsewhere.
Cleveland Browns: Either through the draft or free agency, another starter must be found across from Joe Haden.
Indianapolis Colts: The Colts would like to pair someone across from Vontae Davis.
Jacksonville Jaguars: Gus Bradley will aim to reshape this defense with big, physical corners.
Miami Dolphins: After losing Davis and likely Sean Smith, the cupboard is bare.
Minnesota Vikings: There's a problem with age -- and talent -- at corner.
New England Patriots: The Ravens made it clear New England still has issues in the secondary.
New York Giants: Big Blue could use more depth on the backside.
Oakland Raiders: The Raiders are dying for help.
Philadelphia Eagles: Chip Kelly's defense is going to look very different this season.
San Diego Chargers: The Chargers are reshuffling the deck on both sides of the ball.
San Francisco 49ers: As a few readers pointed out, the 49ers need reliable help at the position.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: The league's worst pass defense needs bodies fast.
Tennessee Titans: No team in the NFL allowed more points than Tennessee last season.
Washington Redskins: DeAngelo Hall isn't getting any younger and there isn't much behind him.

Follow Marc Sessler on Twitter @MarcSesslerNFL.