Around the NFL  

 

Top 85 free agents: Andre Smith available

This year's free-agent crop is a lot like this year's draft class: It's not that exciting at the top, but there is better depth than usual.

Ranked below: My top 85 free agents. This is not a list of the 85 players who will make the most money. It's the list of players I'd want, divided into five tiers.

Let me know where you disagree.

TIER 1: Impact starters

1) Mike Wallace, WR, Pittsburgh Steelers: Speed kills. He might not be a complete receiver, but there's no reason Wallace can't get Vincent Jackson money. (UPDATE: Signed with the Miami Dolphins.)

2) Sebastian Vollmer, OT, New England Patriots: Vollmer is a young, quality starter who is more important to the Patriots' future than Wes Welker. This is where some of Tom Brady's cap savings might go. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with New England Patriots.)

3) Andre Smith, OT, Cincinnati Bengals: No one is making fun of Smith's man boobs now. The Bengals chose to tag Michael Johnson, so Smith is in position to hit the market.

4) Andy Levitre, G, Buffalo Bills: It will be fascinating to see if Levitre gets the big-time money usually due to above-average starting guards. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with Tennessee Titans.)

5) Greg Jennings, WR, Green Bay Packers: Route running and yards after the catch are two skills that work in any system. (UPDATE: Signed with the Minnesota Vikings.)

6) Cliff Avril, DE, Detroit Lions: He's not great against the run and only played 66 percent of Detroit's defensive snaps in 2012, but Avril hustles and gets to the quarterback. He's a solid bookend starter who will be paid like a great one. (UPDATE: Signed with the Seattle Seahawks)

7) Wes Welker, WR, New England Patriots: He's still probably worth more to the Patriots than any other team. Don't be surprised if he stays put. (UPDATE: Signed with the Denver Broncos)

8) Dashon Goldson, S, San Francisco 49ers: Goldson is versatile and tough. It's a little worrisome the 49ers were so willing to let him hit the market. (UPDATE: Signed with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.)

9) Tony Gonzalez, TE, Atlanta Falcons: Gonzalez is coming back, and it's expected to be for the Falcons. As free agency gets set to kick off, Gonzo is technically headed for free agency. (UPDATE: Re-signed with the Atlanta Falcons)

TIER 2: Solid starters


10) Paul Kruger, OLB/DE, Baltimore Ravens: Be leery of paying a Dexter Jackson-like Super Bowl tax to Kruger. Especially when he mostly sat in the Super Bowl in favor of Courtney Upshaw in run defense.  (UPDATE: Signed with the Cleveland Browns.) 

11) Jake Long, OT, Miami Dolphins: Will a team get early-career Jake Long or late-career Tony Boselli? Long is a prime candidate to get overpaid. (UPDATE: Long agreed to a four-year, $34 million contract with the St. Louis Rams.)

12) Sean Smith, CB, Miami Dolphins: A physical player who occasionally looks like a true No. 1 cornerback ... at least for a few games at a time. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Kansas City Chiefs)

13) Brent Grimes, CB, Atlanta Falcons: He'd be among the top 10 players if not for the torn Achilles' tendon suffered in Week 1 last year. Grimes could sign a short-term deal, but his talent is worth the risk. (UPDATE: The Dolphins signed Grimes to a one-year, $5.5 million contract, according to NFL.com's Ian Rapoport.)

14) Aqib Talib, CB, New England Patriots: I'd take my chances with Grimes over Talib, whose on-field play can be as erratic as his off-field behavior. (UPDATE: Signed a one-year contract with the Patriots.)

15) Phil Loadholt, G, Minnesota Vikings: Loadholt is a throwback to the days when right tackles were maulers in the run game and not great at protecting the quarterback. Hidden value: His name is Loadholt. (UPDATE: Re-signed a multi-year deal with the Vikings.)

16) Dannell Ellerbe, LB, Baltimore Ravens: The Ray Lewis-sized hole at the core of Baltimore's defense makes the versatile Ellerbe a priority to re-sign. He can rush, cover and stop the run. (UPDATE: Signed with the Dolphins.)

Debate: Toughest shoes to fill?
Was Bruce Arians' exit from Indianapolis to coach the Cardinals the most impactful departure of the offseason? More ...

17) Chris Houston, CB, Detroit Lions: The cornerback market is deep this year, and there's not a huge gap within the top seven guys at the position. (UPDATE: Houston agreed to return to the Lions.)

18) Antoine Winfield, CB, Minnesota Vikings: He's still one of the best run-stopping cornerbacks in the NFL and can help a team looking for a slot defender. (UPDATE: Winfield was signed by the Seahawks.)

19) Keenan Lewis, CB, Pittsburgh Steelers: Lewis quietly stepped up as Pittsburgh's best cover corner in 2012 at age 26. (UPDATE: Signed with the New Orleans Saints)

20) Dustin Keller, TE, New York Jets: Yes, there's a chance he gets a whole lot better away from Mark Sanchez, Tony Sparano and the rest of the Jets' offensive morass. (UPDATE: Signed with Miami Dolphins.)

21) Ed Reed, S, Baltimore Ravens: His post-Super Bowl/Oscars hangover could be mitigated if picked up by the Colts (Chuck Pagano) or the Patriots (Bill Belichick). (UPDATE: Signed two-year deal with Houston Texans.)

22) Danny Amendola, WR, St. Louis Rams: OK, here's a receiver who should be compared to Welker. This former "Hard Knocks" hero in Dallas is a great slot man who can't shake the injury bug. (UPDATE: Signed with the New England Patriots)

23) Glover Quin, S, Houston Texans: Defensive coordinator Wade Phillips was smart to make Quin's cover skills at safety a huge part of his defense. Now the Texans will have to pay to keep him. (UPDATE: Signed with the Detroit Lions)

24) Fred Davis, TE, Washington Redskins: Davis was one of the league's most promising young tight ends before tearing his Achilles' tendon. He could be a great bargain. (UPDATED: Signed with the Redskins.)

25) Michael Bennett, DE, Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Martellus' brother quietly emerged as a difference maker in Greg Schiano's defense. (UPDATE: Signed with the Seattle Seahawks.)

26) Kenny Phillips, S, New York Giants: Injuries have sapped Phillips' reliability, but he's proven to be a plus starter when he's on the field. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Philadelphia Eagles)

27) Brandon Moore, G, New York Jets: He's so much more than one-half of the "Butt Fumble." Moore can upgrade a lot of starting units.

TIER 3: Starters with questions

28) Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, CB, Philadelphia Eagles: It's not a great sign that two teams have seemingly given up on DRC in his young career. But how much cash would he have commanded if on the market after his second pro season? (UPDATE: Rodgers-Cromartie signed with the Broncos.)

29) Ahmad Bradshaw, RB, New York Giants: A 26-year-old who seems to have the body of a 30-year-old. But there is no better free-agent running back when healthy.

30) Dwight Freeney, DE, Indianapolis Colts: It wasn't just about the scheme change. Freeney hasn't been that explosive for the last two years. (UPDATE: Signed with the Chargers.)

31) Osi Umenyiora, DE, New York Giants: Like Freeney, Osi is best deployed in smaller doses as a situational pass rusher. (UPDATE: Umenyiora signed with the Falcons.)

32) Richard Seymour, DL, Oakland Raiders: There are health and motivation concerns with Seymour headed for a steep pay cut.

33) Sam Baker, OT, Atlanta Falcons: Baker will be the perfect test case for proving what an average starting tackle gets on the open market. (UPDATE: Baker has signed a six-year contract to remain with the Falcons.)

34) Jermon Bushrod, OT, New Orleans Saints: Bushrod will be the perfect test case for proving what an average starting tackle with a random Pro Bowl nod gets on the market. (UPDATE: Agreed to five-year deal with the Bears.)

35) Desmond Bryant, DT, Oakland Raiders: Recent arrest notwithstanding, Bryant is a massive man with a lot of unharnessed talent. (UPDATE: Bryant has agreed to sign with the Browns, NFL.com's Albert Breer reported.)

The evolution of the NFL:
Take a look at how the NFL has evolved from its humble roots, and the efforts being made to ensure it continues to grow.

36) Connor Barwin, DE, Houston Texans: He should have taken Houston's long-term contract offer before 2012. Barwin suffered through a disastrous year, ranking among the worst starting defensive ends in the league by ProFootballFocus. At least he's young with a history of production. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Philadelphia Eagles)

37) Delanie Walker, TE, San Francisco 49ers: The proverbial "movable chess piece," to use a Greg Cosell-ism. He will block your face off even if his hands are suspect. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Titans.)

38) Jared Cook, TE, Tennessee Titans: The Titans chose not to use the franchise tag on Cook, an enigmatic talent who has never lived up to his potential as a big-time playmaker. (UPDATE: Signed with the St. Louis Rams.)

39) Michael Huff, DB, Oakland Raiders: The Raiders released Huff. He's still a quality safety who can start at cornerback too. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Baltimore Ravens

40) Steven Jackson, RB, St. Louis Rams: The veteran back can handle goal-line carries and passing downs, but there is a big risk of paying for past production. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Atlanta Falcons)

41) Nnamdi Asomugha, CB, Philadelphia Eagles: Some team will think they can turn Asomugha around, but it's an act of faith. (UPDATE: Asomugha agreed to a contact with the 49ers.)

42) Rashard Mendenhall, RB, Pittsburgh Steelers: He's a talented young player with potential to be an above-average starter at a cheap price. On the downside: Even Mike Tomlin couldn't get through to him. (UPDATE: Signed with the Arizona Cardinals.)

43) Eric Winston, OT, Kansas City Chiefs: A solid short-term solution at right tackle. The biggest question: Why has he been cut twice in two years other than his high salaries?

44) Martellus Bennett, TE, New York Giants: If you can overlook the flaky off-field persona, Bennett fits the mold as a complete tight end who can block and catch. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Bears.)

45) James Harrison, LB, Pittsburgh Steelers: He was paid too much by the Steelers, but Harrison was their best pass rusher by the end of last year. He should still have an effective season left as a starting OLB. (UPDATE: Signed with the Cincinnati Bengals.)

46) Gosder Cherilus, OT, Detroit Lions: The longtime punching bag proved last year he can survive just fine as a starter. (UPDATE: Signed with the Colts.)

47) Derek Cox, CB, Jacksonville Jaguars: Cox struggles to stay healthy, but there's a lot of talent here. He makes a fine gamble. (UPDATE: Cox agreed to terms with the San Diego Chargers.)

48) Reggie Bush, RB, Miami Dolphins: Bush is a role player, but he's a very useful role player if deployed correctly. (UPDATE: Signed with the Detroit Lions.)

49) Dunta Robinson, CB, Atlanta Falcons He wasn't worth top-tier cornerback money, but Robinson is still capable of playing a lot of snaps. (UPDATE: Robinson agreed to a three-year deal with Kansas City.)

50) Spin the wheel of starting kickers (Steven Hauschka, Mike Nugent, Jason Hanson): There are too many quality kickers available this offseason. It shouldn't be too hard to find one. (UPDATE: Hanson retired, Nugent signed with the Bengals and Hauschka re-signed with the Seahawks.)

TIER 4: Effective in the right role

51) Adam Jones, CB, Cincinnati Bengals: I'm afraid of what would happen to the former Pacman away from Bengals defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer, but Jones was an excellent slot cornerback and return man last season. (UPDATE: Jones agreed to a three-year contract to remain in Cincy.)

52) Ryan Fitzpatrick, QB, Buffalo Bills: He wasn't worth $10 million, but he's better than almost any backup in the league. (UPDATE: Fitzpatrick agreed to a two-year deal with the Tennessee Titans.)

53) Jason Jones, DL, Seattle Seahawks: Jones can be dominant for stretches. A nice rotational player. (UPDATE: Agreed to terms with the Lions.)

54) Cary Williams, CB, Baltimore Ravens: It has to count for something that he was able to hold up as Baltimore's best starting corner by the end of the season. (UPDATE: Signed with the Philadelphia Eagles)

55) Mike DeVito, DE, New York Jets: DeVito has been an unsung hero for the Jets for years. He could fit nicely into a lot of 3-4 defenses. (UPDATE: DeVito agreed to three-year deal with the Chiefs.)

56) Bradley Fletcher, CB, St. Louis Rams: At times, Fletcher has looked like an above-average starting cornerback. At worst, he won't kill your team. (UPDATE: Fletcher was signed by the Eagles.)

Kinkhabwala: White House welcome
Aditi Kinkhabwala says the Ravens' visit with President Obama was marked by a certain friendly familiarity. More ...

57) LaRon Landry, S, New York Jets: A Pro Bowl year with the Jets helped rehab Landry's value, but he's still a bigger name than impact player. (UPDATE: Landry signed a four-year deal with the Colts.)

58) Louis Delmas, S, Detroit Lions: Injuries have sapped his explosiveness as a tackler and Delmas was never the most instinctive player in coverage. (UPDATE: Delmas has agreed to a two-year deal with the Lions).

59) Willie Colon, G/T, Pittsburgh Steelers: He's struggled with injuries, but Colon is still a mauler in the running game. (UPDATE: Signed a one-year deal with the Jets.)

60) Matt Cassel, QB, Kansas City Chiefs: He's better than a few starters out there (like Christian Ponder) but would be better suited for a backup role for Christian Ponder. (UPDATE: Signed with the Minnesota Vikings)

61) Matt Shaughnessy, DE, Oakland Raiders: Once wildly underrated, Shaughnessy has lost two seasons to injury and ineffectiveness. He could be a nice bargain. (UPDATE: Signed a one-year deal with the Arizona Cardinals.)

62) Israel Idonije, DE, Chicago Bears: Idonije offers quality veteran snaps for a low price.

63) Beanie Wells, RB, Arizona CardinalsThe disappointing first-round pick could still help a team looking for a short-yardage back. 

64) Rey Maualuga, ILB, Cincinnati Bengals: Coach Marvin Lewis told Around The League he wanted Maualuga back, but at what price? The USC product has never quite stepped up to leadership status. (UPDATE: Re-signed with the Cincinnati Bengals)

65) Daryl Smith, LB, Jacksonville Jaguars: One of the most underrated linebackers of his era, Smith is coming off major injury. (UPDATE: Signed a one-year deal with the Ravens)

Free-agent tracker
NFL free agency is underway. Follow all of the latest player rumors and signings in our free-agent tracker. More...

66) Louis Vasquez, G, San Diego Chargers: You could do a lot worse if your team is desperate for a starting guard.  (UPDATE: Signed with Denver Broncos.)

67) Antoine Cason, CB, San Diego Chargers: A.J. Smith's former first-round pick never lived up to his draft slot, but he's not a bad starter. (UPDATE: Signed with Arizona Cardinals.)

68) John Abraham, DE, Atlanta Falcons: The Falcons need pass rush help and still chose not to keep Abraham around for a $4.25 million base salary. That's not a great sign. 

69) Shane Lechler, P, Oakland Raiders: The best punter of his era picked a bad time to have a down season. (UPDATE: Lechler signed with the Houston Texans.)

70) Erin Henderson, LB, Minnesota Vikings: Two-down linebackers don't get paid much, but Henderson should be able to help a team stop the run. (UPDATE: Henderson re-signed with the Vikings.)

71) Bryant McKinnie, OT, Baltimore Ravens: McKinnie's playoff run was rather epic, but teams don't trust it will happen again. (UPDATE: McKinnie re-signed with the Ravens.)

72) Brandon Lloyd, WR, New England Patriots: No surprise if he returns to New England.

73) Mike Jenkins, CB, Dallas Cowboys:
I stubbornly remember the moments that Jenkins looked like a solid pro (UPDATE: Jenkins signed with the Oakland Raiders.)

74) Adrian Wilson, S, Arizona Cardinals: Veteran leadership at a cheap price. (UPDATE: Signed with New England Patriots.)

Instant Debate: Riskiest free agent?
Who are the potential busts on the open market this offseason? Our analysts identify candidates, including Greg Jennings. More ...

75) Sedrick Ellis, DT, New Orleans Saints: The former No. 7 overall pick has shown flashes, but has quietly been one of the bigger busts of the last five years.

76) Cullen Jenkins, DT, Philadelphia Eagles: He can still help teams in a rotation. A return to Green Bay makes sense. (UPDATE: Jenkins signed with the Giants, NFL.com's Kimberly Jones reported.)

77) Philip Wheeler, LB, Oakland Raiders: Wheeler proved last year he can fit into a variety of systems. (UPDATE: Signed with the Dolphins.)

78) Charles Woodson, S, Green Bay Packers: The potential Hall of Famer needs a coach who can hide his lack of speed. (UPDATE: Woodson returned to his original team when he signed with the Oakland Raiders.)

79) Felix Jones, RB, Dallas Cowboys: Jones is like a less reliable Reggie Bush, which doesn't sound like a compliment. (UPDATE: Jones signed a one-year deal with the Eagles.)

80) Glenn Dorsey, DE, Kansas City Chiefs: Drafted No. 5 overall in 2008, Dorsey has stretches where he stops the run well. (UPDATE: Signed with the 49ers)

81) Brad Jones, LB, Green Bay Packers: Jones proved last year he can play inside. He makes a perfect reserve who can start at multiple positions. (UPDATE: The Packers brought back Jones)

82) Brian Urlacher, LB, Chicago Bears: It's more than a little sad to rank him behind Brad Jones.

83) Danny Woodhead, RB, New England Patriots: He probably wouldn't make sense away from the Patriots as a reliable third-down back. (UPDATE: Signed two-year deal with the San Diego Chargers.)

84) Chris Clemons, S, Miami DolphinsA solid starter coming off his best season. (UPDATE: Re-signed with Dolphins for one year). 

85) Julian Edelman, WR, New England PatriotsSee Danny Woodhead. (UPDATE: The Patriots re-signed Edelman.)

Follow Gregg Rosenthal on Twitter @GreggRosenthal.

Fan Discussion

NFL News
CONTENT
15