- History
| 2019 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 2 | 34 | Rock Ya-Sin | CB | Temple |
| 2 | 49 | Ben Banogu | DE | Texas Christian |
| 2 | 59 | Parris Campbell | WR | Ohio State |
| 3 | 89 | Bobby Okereke | ILB | Stanford |
| 4 | 109 | Khari Willis | SAF | Michigan State |
| 5 | 144 | Marvell Tell | SAF | USC |
| 5 | 164 | E.J. Speed | LB | Tarleton State |
| 6 | 199 | Gerri Green | LB | Mississippi State |
| 7 | 240 | Jackson Barton | T | Utah |
| 7 | 246 | Javon Patterson | C | Mississippi |
| 2018 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 6 | Quenton Nelson | G | Notre Dame |
| 2 | 36 | Darius Leonard | LB | South Carolina State |
| 2 | 37 | Braden Smith | G | Auburn |
| 2 | 52 | Kemoko Turay | LB | Rutgers |
| 2 | 64 | Tyquan Lewis | DE | Ohio State |
| 4 | 104 | Nyheim Hines | RB | North Carolina State |
| 5 | 159 | Daurice Fountain | WR | Northern Iowa |
| 5 | 169 | Jordan Wilkins | RB | Mississippi |
| 6 | 185 | Deon Cain | WR | Clemson |
| 7 | 221 | Matthew Adams | LB | Houston |
| 7 | 235 | Zaire Franklin | LB | Syracuse |
| 2017 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 15 | Malik Hooker | SAF | Ohio State |
| 2 | 46 | Quincy Wilson | CB | Florida |
| 3 | 80 | Tarell Basham | DE | Ohio U. |
| 4 | 137 | Zach Banner | T | USC |
| 4 | 143 | Marlon Mack | RB | South Florida |
| 4 | 144 | Grover Stewart | DT | Albany State (Ga.) |
| 5 | 158 | Nate Hairston | CB | Temple |
| 5 | 161 | Anthony Walker | LB | Northwestern |
| 2016 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 18 | Ryan Kelly | C | Alabama |
| 2 | 57 | T.J. Green | SAF | Clemson |
| 3 | 82 | Le'Raven Clark | T | Texas Tech |
| 4 | 116 | Hassan Ridgeway | DT | Texas |
| 4 | 125 | Antonio Morrison | LB | Florida |
| 5 | 155 | Joe Haeg | T | North Dakota State |
| 7 | 239 | Trevor Bates | LB | Maine |
| 7 | 248 | Austin Blythe | C | Iowa |
| 2015 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 29 | Phillip Dorsett | WR | Miami (Fla.) |
| 3 | 65 | D'Joun Smith | CB | Florida Atlantic |
| 3 | 93 | Henry Anderson | DE | Stanford |
| 4 | 109 | Clayton Geathers | SAF | Central Florida |
| 5 | 151 | David Parry | NT | Stanford |
| 6 | 205 | Josh Robinson | RB | Mississippi State |
| 6 | 207 | Amarlo Herrera | LB | Georgia |
| 7 | 255 | Denzelle Good | T | Mars Hill |
| 2014 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 2 | 59 | Jack Mewhort | T | Ohio State |
| 3 | 90 | Donte Moncrief | WR | Mississippi |
| 5 | 166 | Jonathan Newsome | DE | Ball State |
| 6 | 203 | Andrew Jackson | LB | Western Kentucky |
| 7 | 232 | John Ulrick | T | Georgia State |
| 2013 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 24 | Bjoern Werner | OLB | Florida State |
| 3 | 86 | Hugh Thornton | OG | Illinois |
| 4 | 121 | Khaled Holmes | C | USC |
| 5 | 139 | Montori Hughes | DT | Tennessee-Martin |
| 6 | 192 | John Boyett | SS | Oregon |
| 7 | 230 | Kerwynn Williams | RB | Utah State |
| 7 | 254 | Justice Cunningham | TE | South Carolina |
| 2012 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | Andrew Luck | QB | Stanford |
| 2 | 34 | Coby Fleener | TE | Stanford |
| 3 | 64 | Dwayne Allen | TE | Clemson |
| 3 | 92 | T.Y. Hilton | WR | Florida International |
| 5 | 136 | Josh Chapman | DT | Alabama |
| 5 | 170 | Vick Ballard | RB | Mississippi State |
| 6 | 206 | LaVon Brazill | WR | Ohio U. |
| 7 | 208 | Justin Anderson | G | Georgia |
| 7 | 214 | Tim Fugger | LB | Vanderbilt |
| 7 | 253 | Chandler Harnish | QB | Northern Illinois |
| 2011 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 22 | Anthony Castonzo | T | Boston College |
| 2 | 49 | Ben Ijalana | T | Villanova |
| 3 | 87 | Drake Nevis | DT | LSU |
| 4 | 119 | Delone Carter | RB | Syracuse |
| 6 | 188 | Chris Rucker | DB | Michigan State |
| 2010 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 31 | Jerry Hughes | DE | Texas Christian |
| 2 | 63 | Pat Angerer | OLB | Iowa |
| 3 | 94 | Kevin Thomas | DB | USC |
| 4 | 129 | Jacques McClendon | G | Tennessee |
| 5 | 162 | Brody Eldridge | TE | Oklahoma |
| 7 | 238 | Ricardo Mathews | DE | Cincinnati |
| 7 | 240 | Kavell Conner | OLB | Clemson |
| 7 | 246 | Ray Fisher | DB | Indiana |
| 2009 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 27 | Donald Brown | RB | Connecticut |
| 2 | 56 | Fili Moala | DT | USC |
| 3 | 92 | Jerraud Powers | DB | Auburn |
| 4 | 127 | Austin Collie | WR | Brigham Young |
| 4 | 136 | Terrance Taylor | DT | Michigan |
| 6 | 201 | Curtis Painter | QB | Purdue |
| 7 | 222 | Pat McAfee | P | West Virginia |
| 7 | 236 | Jaimie Thomas | G | Maryland |
| 2008 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 2 | 59 | Mike Pollak | G | Arizona State |
| 3 | 93 | Philip Wheeler | OLB | Georgia Tech |
| 4 | 127 | Jacob Tamme | TE | Kentucky |
| 5 | 161 | Marcus Howard | DE | Georgia |
| 6 | 196 | Tom Santi | TE | Virginia |
| 6 | 201 | Steve Justice | C | Wake Forest |
| 6 | 202 | Mike Hart | RB | Michigan |
| 6 | 205 | Pierre Garcon | WR | Mount Union |
| 7 | 236 | Jamey Richard | C | Buffalo |
| 2007 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 32 | Anthony Gonzalez | WR | Ohio State |
| 2 | 42 | Tony Ugoh | T | Arkansas |
| 3 | 95 | Dante Hughes | CB | California |
| 3 | 98 | Quinn Pitcock | DT | Ohio State |
| 4 | 131 | Brannon Condren | DB | Troy State |
| 4 | 136 | Clint Session | LB | Pittsburgh |
| 5 | 169 | Roy Hall | WR | Ohio State |
| 5 | 173 | Michael Coe | CB | Alabama State |
| 7 | 242 | Keyunta Dawson | DT | Texas Tech |
| 2006 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 30 | Joseph Addai | RB | Louisiana State |
| 2 | 62 | Tim Jennings | CB | Georgia |
| 3 | 94 | Freddie Keiaho | LB | San Diego State |
| 5 | 162 | Michael Toudouze | G | Texas Christian |
| 6 | 199 | Charlie Johnson | T | Oklahoma State |
| 6 | 207 | Antoine Bethea | SS | Howard |
| 7 | 238 | T.J. Rushing | CB | Stanford |
| 2005 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 29 | Marlin Jackson | DB | Michigan |
| 2 | 60 | Kelvin Hayden | DB | Illinois |
| 3 | 92 | Vincent Burns | DE | Kentucky |
| 4 | 129 | Dylan Gandy | G | Texas Tech |
| 4 | 135 | Matt Giordano | DB | California |
| 5 | 148 | Jonathan Welsh | DE | Wisconsin |
| 5 | 165 | Robert Hunt | C | North Dakota State |
| 5 | 173 | Tyjuan Hagler | LB | Cincinnati |
| 6 | 202 | Dave Rayner | K | Michigan State |
| 7 | 243 | Anthony Davis | -- | Wisconsin |
| 2004 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 2 | 44 | Bob Sanders | DB | Iowa |
| 3 | 68 | Ben Hartsock | TE | Ohio State |
| 3 | 69 | Gilbert Gardner | LB | Purdue |
| 4 | 107 | Kendyll Pope | LB | Florida State |
| 4 | 125 | Jason David | CB | Washington State |
| 5 | 141 | Jake Scott | G | Idaho |
| 6 | 173 | Von Hutchins | DB | Mississippi |
| 6 | 193 | Jim Sorgi | QB | Wisconsin |
| 7 | 229 | David Kimball | K | Penn State |
| 2003 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 24 | Dallas Clark | TE | Iowa |
| 2 | 58 | Mike Doss | SS | Ohio State |
| 3 | 90 | Donald Strickland | FS | Colorado |
| 4 | 122 | Steve Sciullo | G | Marshall |
| 5 | 138 | Robert Mathis | DE | Alabama A&M |
| 5 | 162 | Keyon Whiteside | LB | Tennessee |
| 6 | 198 | Cato June | DB | Michigan |
| 6 | 208 | Makoa Freitas | T | Arizona |
| 2002 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 11 | Dwight Freeney | DE | Syracuse |
| 2 | 42 | Larry Tripplett | DT | Washington |
| 3 | 74 | Joseph Jefferson | CB | Western Kentucky |
| 4 | 106 | David Thornton | LB | North Carolina |
| 6 | 182 | David Pugh | DT | Virginia Tech |
| 6 | 183 | James Lewis | -- | Miami (Fla.) |
| 6 | 204 | Brian Allen | RB | Stanford |
| 7 | 220 | Josh Mallard | DE | Georgia |
| 2001 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 30 | Reggie Wayne | WR | Miami (Fla.) |
| 2 | 37 | Idrees Bashir | FS | Memphis |
| 3 | 91 | Cory Bird | DB | Virginia Tech |
| 4 | 118 | Ryan Diem | G | Northern Illinois |
| 5 | 152 | Raymond Walls | DB | Southern Mississippi |
| 6 | 193 | Jason Doering | DB | Wisconsin |
| 7 | 220 | Rick DeMulling | G | Idaho |
| 2000 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 28 | Rob Morris | LB | Brigham Young |
| 2 | 59 | Marcus Washington | LB | Auburn |
| 3 | 91 | David Macklin | DB | Penn State |
| 4 | 122 | Josh Williams | DT | Michigan |
| 5 | 138 | Matt Johnson | -- | Brigham Young |
| 7 | 235 | Rob Renes | DT | Michigan |
| 7 | 238 | Rodregis Brooks | DB | Alabama-Birmingham |
| 1999 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 4 | Edgerrin James | RB | Miami (Fla.) |
| 2 | 36 | Mike Peterson | OLB | Florida |
| 3 | 63 | Brandon Burlsworth | -- | Arkansas |
| 4 | 96 | Paul Miranda | DB | Central Florida |
| 5 | 138 | Brad Scioli | DE | Penn State |
| 7 | 210 | Hunter Smith | P | Notre Dame |
| 7 | 250 | Corey Terry | DE | Tennessee |
| 1998 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | Peyton Manning | QB | Tennessee |
| 2 | 32 | Jerome Pathon | WR | Washington |
| 3 | 71 | E.G. Green | WR | Florida State |
| 4 | 93 | Steve McKinney | G | Texas A&M |
| 5 | 135 | Antony Jordan | LB | Vanderbilt |
| 7 | 190 | Aaron Taylor | G | Nebraska |
| 7 | 231 | Cory Gaines | -- | Tennessee |
| 1997 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 19 | Tarik Glenn | G | California |
| 2 | 48 | Adam Meadows | T | Georgia |
| 3 | 86 | Bertrand Berry | LB | Notre Dame |
| 4 | 117 | Monty Montgomery | DB | Houston |
| 5 | 150 | Nate Jacquet | WR | San Diego State |
| 5 | 156 | Carl Powell | DE | Louisville |
| 6 | 182 | Scott Von der Ahe | LB | Arizona State |
| 7 | 219 | Clarence Thompson | -- | Knoxville |
| 1996 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 19 | Marvin Harrison | WR | Syracuse |
| 2 | 51 | Dedric Mathis | CB | Houston |
| 3 | 82 | Scott Slutzker | TE | Iowa |
| 4 | 115 | Brian Milne | FB | Penn State |
| 5 | 151 | Steve Martin | DT | Missouri |
| 6 | 191 | Keith Conlin | -- | Penn State |
| 6 | 205 | Mike Cawley | -- | James Madison |
| 7 | 232 | Adrian Robinson | -- | Baylor |
| 1995 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 15 | Ellis Johnson | DE | Florida |
| 2 | 48 | Ken Dilger | TE | Illinois |
| 3 | 79 | Zack Crockett | RB | Florida State |
| 4 | 114 | Ray McElroy | DB | Eastern Illinois |
| 5 | 149 | Derek West | T | Colorado |
| 6 | 187 | Brian Gelzheiser | -- | Penn State |
| 7 | 223 | Jessie Cox | -- | Texas Southern |
| 1994 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 2 | Marshall Faulk | RB | San Diego State |
| 1 | 5 | Trev Alberts | LB | Nebraska |
| 2 | 32 | Eric Mahlum | G | California |
| 3 | 67 | Jason Mathews | T | Texas A&M |
| 4 | 106 | Brad Banta | TE | USC |
| 5 | 133 | John Covington | DB | Notre Dame |
| 6 | 164 | Lamont Warren | RB | Colorado |
| 7 | 196 | Lance Teichelman | DT | Texas A&M |
| 1993 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 16 | Sean Dawkins | WR | California |
| 2 | 49 | Roosevelt Potts | RB | Louisiana-Monroe |
| 3 | 65 | Ray Buchanan | DB | Louisville |
| 4 | 92 | Derwin Gray | DB | Brigham Young |
| 4 | 107 | Devon McDonald | LB | Notre Dame |
| 6 | 157 | Carlos Etheredge | TE | Miami (Fla.) |
| 7 | 184 | Lance Lewis | -- | Nebraska |
| 8 | 211 | Marquise Thomas | LB | Mississippi |
| 1992 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | Steve Emtman | DE | Washington |
| 1 | 2 | Quentin Coryatt | ILB | Texas A&M |
| 2 | 29 | Ashley Ambrose | DB | Mississippi Valley State |
| 4 | 85 | Rodney Culver | RB | Notre Dame |
| 4 | 105 | Tony McCoy | NT | Florida |
| 5 | 113 | Maury Toy | -- | UCLA |
| 6 | 141 | Shoun Habersham | WR | Tennessee-Chattanooga |
| 7 | 169 | Derek Steele | -- | Maryland |
| 8 | 197 | Jason Belser | DB | Oklahoma |
| 8 | 212 | Ronald Humphrey | RB | Mississippi Valley State |
| 9 | 225 | Eddie Miller | WR | South Carolina |
| 10 | 253 | Steve Grant | LB | West Virginia |
| 12 | 309 | Michael Brandon | DE | Florida |
| 1991 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 2 | 40 | Shane Curry | DE | Miami (Fla.) |
| 3 | 69 | Dave McCloughan | DB | Colorado |
| 4 | 96 | Mark Vander Poel | T | Colorado |
| 5 | 125 | Kerry Cash | TE | Texas |
| 6 | 152 | Mel Agee | DE | Illinois |
| 7 | 181 | James Bradley | -- | Michigan State |
| 8 | 208 | Tim Bruton | TE | Missouri |
| 9 | 236 | Howard Griffith | RB | Illinois |
| 10 | 263 | Frank Giannetti | DE | Penn State |
| 11 | 292 | Jerry Crafts | T | Louisville |
| 12 | 319 | Rob Luedeke | -- | Penn State |
| 1990 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | Jeff George | QB | Illinois |
| 2 | 36 | Anthony Johnson | RB | Notre Dame |
| 4 | 83 | Stacey Simmons | WR | Florida |
| 4 | 94 | Bill Schultz | G | USC |
| 4 | 103 | Alan Grant | DB | Stanford |
| 4 | 106 | Rick Cunningham | T | Texas A&M |
| 6 | 148 | Tony Walker | LB | Southeast Missouri State |
| 7 | 179 | James Singletary | -- | East Carolina |
| 8 | 206 | Ken Clark | RB | Nebraska |
| 8 | 213 | Harvey Wilson | -- | Southern University |
| 9 | 232 | Darvell Huffman | WR | Boston U. |
| 11 | 290 | Carnel Smith | -- | Pittsburgh |
| 12 | 311 | Gene Benhart | QB | Western Illinois |
| 12 | 316 | Dean Brown | -- | Notre Dame |
| 1989 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 22 | Andre Rison | WR | Michigan State |
| 3 | 72 | Mitchell Benson | NT | Texas Christian |
| 4 | 99 | Pat Tomberlin | G | Florida State |
| 6 | 155 | Quintus McDonald | LB | Penn State |
| 7 | 182 | Ivy Joe Hunter | RB | Kentucky |
| 7 | 185 | Charles Washington | DB | Cameron |
| 8 | 212 | Kurt Larson | LB | Michigan State |
| 9 | 239 | William Mackall | -- | Tennessee-Martin |
| 10 | 266 | Jim Thompson | -- | Auburn |
| 11 | 296 | Wayne Johnson | QB | Georgia |
| 12 | 314 | William DuBose | -- | South Carolina State |
| 12 | 323 | Steve Taylor | -- | Nebraska |
| 1988 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 3 | 76 | Chris Chandler | QB | Washington |
| 4 | 104 | Michael Ball | DB | Southern University |
| 5 | 129 | John Baylor | DB | Southern Mississippi |
| 9 | 243 | Jeff Herrod | LB | Mississippi |
| 10 | 270 | O'Brien Alston | LB | Maryland |
| 11 | 297 | Donnie Dee | TE | Tulsa |
| 12 | 308 | Aatron Kenney | -- | Wis.-Stevens Point |
| 12 | 327 | Tim Vesling | -- | Syracuse |
| 1987 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 2 | Cornelius Bennett | LB | Alabama |
| 3 | 58 | Chris Gambol | T | Iowa |
| 4 | 85 | Randy Dixon | T | Pittsburgh |
| 5 | 114 | Roy Banks | WR | Eastern Illinois |
| 6 | 142 | Freddie Robinson | DB | Alabama |
| 7 | 170 | Mark Bellini | WR | Brigham Young |
| 8 | 200 | Chuckie Miller | DB | UCLA |
| 9 | 247 | Bob Ontko | LB | Penn State |
| 10 | 253 | Chris Goode | DB | Alabama |
| 11 | 281 | Jim Reynosa | -- | Arizona State |
| 12 | 309 | David Adams | RB | Arizona |
| 1986 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 4 | Jon Hand | DE | Alabama |
| 2 | 47 | Jack Trudeau | QB | Illinois |
| 4 | 86 | Bill Brooks | WR | Boston U. |
| 5 | 117 | Scott Kellar | NT | Northern Illinois |
| 5 | 124 | Gary Walker | C | Boston U. |
| 7 | 171 | Steve O'Malley | -- | Northern Illinois |
| 7 | 172 | Chris White | -- | Illinois |
| 7 | 190 | Tommy Sims | DB | Tennessee |
| 8 | 198 | Trell Hooper | DB | Memphis |
| 9 | 228 | Bob Brotzki | T | Syracuse |
| 10 | 266 | Pete Anderson | -- | Georgia |
| 12 | 309 | Steve Wade | -- | Vanderbilt |
| 12 | 326 | Isaac Williams | -- | Florida State |
| 1985 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 5 | Duane Bickett | LB | USC |
| 2 | 32 | Don Anderson | DB | Purdue |
| 3 | 61 | Anthony Young | DB | Temple |
| 4 | 88 | Willie Broughton | DE | Miami (Fla.) |
| 5 | 117 | Roger Caron | T | Harvard |
| 7 | 173 | James Harbour | WR | Mississippi |
| 8 | 200 | Ricky Nichols | WR | East Carolina |
| 9 | 229 | Mark Boyer | TE | USC |
| 10 | 256 | Andre Pinesett | -- | Cal State-Fullerton |
| 12 | 312 | Dave Burnette | T | Arkansas |
| 1984 - Indianapolis Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 8 | Leonard Coleman | DB | Vanderbilt |
| 1 | 19 | Ron Solt | G | Maryland |
| 2 | 35 | Blaise Winter | DE | Syracuse |
| 3 | 66 | Chris Scott | DE | Purdue |
| 4 | 93 | Craig Curry | DB | Texas |
| 4 | 103 | George Wonsley | RB | Mississippi State |
| 5 | 120 | Golden Tate | -- | Tennessee State |
| 5 | 130 | Kevin Call | T | Colorado State |
| 6 | 147 | Dwight Beverly | RB | Illinois |
| 8 | 205 | Eugene Daniel | DB | Louisiana State |
| 11 | 290 | Bob Stowe | -- | Illinois |
| 12 | 317 | Steve Hathaway | LB | West Virginia |
| Albert Bentley | RB | Miami (Fla.) | ||
| Byron Smith | DT | California | ||
| 1983 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | John Elway | QB | Stanford |
| 2 | 29 | Vernon Maxwell | LB | Arizona State |
| 3 | 57 | George Achica | DT | USC |
| 4 | 85 | Phil Smith | WR | San Diego State |
| 5 | 113 | Sid Abramowitz | T | Tulsa |
| 6 | 161 | Grant Feasel | C | Abilene Christian |
| 7 | 169 | Alvin Moore | RB | Arizona State |
| 9 | 225 | Jim Mills | T | Hawaii |
| 9 | 241 | Chris Rose | -- | Stanford |
| 9 | 252 | Ronald Hopkins | -- | Murray State |
| 11 | 280 | Jim Bob Taylor | QB | Georgia Tech |
| 12 | 308 | Carl Williams | -- | Texas Southern |
| 1982 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 2 | Johnie Cooks | LB | Mississippi State |
| 1 | 4 | Art Schlichter | QB | Ohio State |
| 2 | 28 | Leo Wisniewski | NT | Penn State |
| 2 | 34 | Rohn Stark | P | Florida State |
| 3 | 57 | James Burroughs | DB | Michigan State |
| 4 | 84 | Mike Pagel | QB | Arizona State |
| 5 | 113 | Terry Crouch | G | Oklahoma |
| 6 | 140 | Pat Beach | TE | Washington State |
| 7 | 169 | Fletcher Jenkins | DE | Washington |
| 8 | 196 | Tony Loia | -- | Arizona State |
| 9 | 225 | Tony Berryhill | -- | Clemson |
| 10 | 252 | Tom Deery | -- | Widener |
| 11 | 280 | Lamont Meacham | DB | Western Kentucky |
| 12 | 307 | Johnnie Wright | RB | South Carolina |
| 1981 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 12 | Randy McMillan | RB | Pittsburgh |
| 1 | 18 | Donnell Thompson | DE | North Carolina |
| 3 | 68 | Randy Van Divier | T | Washington |
| 4 | 94 | Tim Sherwin | TE | Boston College |
| 6 | 149 | Bubba Green | DT | North Carolina State |
| 7 | 178 | Obed Ariri | K | Clemson |
| 8 | 204 | Ken Sitton | -- | Oklahoma |
| 8 | 220 | Hosea Taylor | DE | Houston |
| 9 | 233 | Tim Gooch | -- | Kentucky |
| 10 | 256 | Gregg Gerken | -- | Northern Arizona |
| 10 | 259 | Trent Bryant | DB | Arkansas |
| 11 | 288 | Holden Smith | WR | California |
| 12 | 315 | Eric Scoggins | LB | USC |
| 1980 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 5 | Curtis Dickey | RB | Texas A&M |
| 1 | 24 | Derrick Hatchett | DB | Texas |
| 2 | 32 | Ray Donaldson | C | Georgia |
| 2 | 51 | Tim Foley | T | Notre Dame |
| 4 | 88 | Ray Butler | WR | USC |
| 6 | 144 | Chris Foote | C | USC |
| 7 | 170 | Wes Roberts | DE | Texas Christian |
| 8 | 195 | Ken Walter | -- | Texas Tech |
| 9 | 227 | Mark Bright | -- | Temple |
| 10 | 254 | Larry Stewart | -- | Maryland |
| 10 | 280 | Eddy Whitley | -- | Kansas State |
| 12 | 311 | Randy Bielski | -- | Towson |
| 12 | 324 | Marvin Sims | FB | Clemson |
| 1979 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 6 | Barry Krauss | LB | Alabama |
| 3 | 69 | Kim Anderson | DB | Arizona State |
| 5 | 115 | Larry Braziel | DB | USC |
| 6 | 150 | Jimmy Moore | G | Ohio State |
| 8 | 197 | Steve Heimkreiter | LB | Notre Dame |
| 8 | 207 | Nesby Glasgow | DB | Washington |
| 9 | 224 | Russ Henderson | -- | Virginia |
| 10 | 254 | Steve Stephens | TE | Oklahoma State |
| 11 | 280 | John Priestner | -- | Western Ontario (Canada) |
| 12 | 306 | Charlie Green | -- | Kansas State |
| 1978 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 25 | Reese McCall | TE | Auburn |
| 2 | 52 | Mike Woods | LB | Cincinnati |
| 5 | 117 | Frank Myers | T | Texas A&M |
| 6 | 161 | Ben Garry | RB | Southern Mississippi |
| 7 | 191 | Jeff Logan | -- | Ohio State |
| 8 | 218 | Monte Anthony | -- | Nebraska |
| 9 | 245 | Dave Studdard | T | Texas |
| 10 | 275 | Dallas Owens | -- | Kentucky |
| 11 | 302 | Henry Mason | -- | Central Missouri State |
| 12 | 329 | Bruce Allen | -- | Richmond |
| 1977 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 26 | Randy Burke | WR | Kentucky |
| 2 | 53 | Mike Ozdowski | DE | Virginia |
| 6 | 163 | Calvin O'Neal | LB | Michigan |
| 7 | 193 | Blanchard Carter | T | Nevada-Las Vegas |
| 8 | 220 | Ken Helms | -- | Georgia |
| 9 | 247 | Glenn Capriola | RB | Boston College |
| 10 | 277 | Ron Baker | G | Oklahoma State |
| 11 | 304 | Brian Ruff | -- | The Citadel |
| 12 | 331 | Bill Deutsch | -- | North Dakota |
| 1976 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 20 | Ken Novak | DT | Purdue |
| 3 | 81 | Ed Simonini | LB | Texas A&M |
| 3 | 90 | Ron Lee | RB | West Virginia |
| 5 | 134 | Sanders Shiver | LB | Carson-Newman |
| 5 | 143 | Mike Kirkland | QB | Arkansas |
| 8 | 228 | Ricky Thompson | WR | Baylor |
| 9 | 258 | Stu Levenick | -- | Illinois |
| 10 | 283 | Tim Baylor | DB | Morgan State |
| 11 | 310 | Rick Gibney | -- | Georgia Tech |
| 12 | 340 | Frank Stavroff | -- | Indiana |
| 14 | 394 | Jeremiah Cummings | -- | Albany State (Ga.) |
| 15 | 424 | Gary Alexander | -- | Clemson |
| 16 | 449 | Mike Fuhrman | -- | Memphis |
| 16 | 451 | Steve Ludwig | -- | Miami (Fla.) |
| 1975 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 3 | Ken Huff | G | North Carolina |
| 3 | 53 | Mike Washington | DB | Alabama |
| 3 | 56 | Dave Pear | NT | Washington |
| 4 | 80 | Marshall Johnson | WR | Houston |
| 4 | 93 | Paul Linford | -- | Brigham Young |
| 5 | 105 | Roosevelt Leaks | RB | Texas |
| 6 | 131 | Donald Westbrook | WR | Nebraska |
| 7 | 157 | Kim Jones | RB | Colorado State |
| 7 | 160 | Steve Joachim | QB | Temple |
| 7 | 168 | Derrel Luce | LB | Baylor |
| 8 | 184 | John Bushong | DE | Western Kentucky |
| 8 | 187 | Greg Denboer | -- | Michigan |
| 8 | 192 | Mario Cage | -- | Northwestern State-Louisiana |
| 9 | 209 | Royce McKinney | DB | Kentucky State |
| 10 | 236 | Phil Waganheim | -- | Maryland |
| 11 | 261 | Dave Hazel | -- | Ohio State |
| 12 | 288 | Brad Storm | -- | Iowa State |
| 13 | 313 | John Roman | T | Idaho State |
| 14 | 340 | Mike Smith | -- | Southern Methodist |
| 15 | 365 | John Goodie | -- | Langston |
| 16 | 392 | Bill Malouf | -- | Mississippi |
| 16 | 399 | Mike Evavold | -- | Macalester |
| 16 | 416 | Bob Smith | -- | Maryland |
| 17 | 417 | David McKnight | -- | Georgia |
| 17 | 426 | Mike Bengard | -- | Northwestern (Ia) |
| 17 | 440 | Frank Russell | -- | Maryland |
| 1974 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 5 | John Dutton | DT | Nebraska |
| 1 | 24 | Roger Carr | WR | Louisiana Tech |
| 2 | 32 | Fred Cook | DE | Southern Mississippi |
| 2 | 37 | Ed Shuttlesworth | -- | Michigan |
| 3 | 57 | Glenn Robinson | DE | Oklahoma State |
| 3 | 67 | Bob Pratt | G | North Carolina |
| 4 | 84 | Tony Bell | -- | Bowling Green State |
| 5 | 129 | Doug Nettles | DB | Vanderbilt |
| 6 | 140 | Danny Rhodes | LB | Arkansas |
| 7 | 161 | Noah Jackson | G | Tampa |
| 7 | 170 | Dan Dickel | LB | Iowa |
| 7 | 174 | Freddie Scott | WR | Amherst |
| 8 | 188 | Greg Latta | TE | Morgan State |
| 8 | 198 | Paul Miles | -- | Bowling Green State |
| 8 | 203 | Greg Hare | -- | Ohio State |
| 10 | 240 | Bob Van Duyne | G | Idaho |
| 10 | 257 | Glenn Ellis | -- | Elon |
| 11 | 265 | Tim Rudnick | DB | Notre Dame |
| 12 | 292 | Dave Simonson | T | Minnesota |
| 12 | 307 | Bob Bobrowski | -- | Purdue |
| 13 | 317 | Randy Hall | DB | Idaho |
| 14 | 344 | Ed Collins | -- | Rice |
| 15 | 369 | Pat Kelly | -- | Richmond |
| 16 | 396 | Dave Margavage | -- | Kentucky |
| 17 | 421 | Tim Berra | WR | Massachusetts |
| 17 | 436 | Buzzy Lewis | -- | Florida State |
| 1973 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 2 | Bert Jones | QB | Louisiana State |
| 1 | 10 | Joe Ehrmann | DT | Syracuse |
| 2 | 35 | Mike Barnes | DT | Miami (Fla.) |
| 3 | 61 | Bill Olds | RB | Nebraska |
| 3 | 62 | Jamie Rotella | -- | Tennessee |
| 4 | 83 | Gery Palmer | T | Kansas |
| 4 | 85 | Ollie Smith | WR | Tennessee State |
| 5 | 114 | David Taylor | T | Catawba |
| 8 | 189 | Ray Oldham | DB | Middle Tennessee State |
| 8 | 191 | Bill Windauer | DT | Iowa |
| 11 | 270 | Dan Neal | C | Kentucky |
| 12 | 295 | Bernard Thomas | -- | Western Michigan |
| 13 | 322 | Tom Pierantozzi | -- | West Chester |
| 14 | 347 | Ed Williams | -- | West Virginia |
| 15 | 374 | Jackie Brown | -- | South Carolina |
| 16 | 399 | Marty Januszkiewicz | -- | Syracuse |
| 17 | 426 | Guy Falkenhagen | -- | Northern Michigan |
| 1972 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 22 | Tom Drougas | T | Oregon |
| 2 | 46 | Jack Mildren | DB | Oklahoma |
| 2 | 47 | Glenn Doughty | WR | Michigan |
| 2 | 48 | Lydell Mitchell | RB | Penn State |
| 4 | 104 | Eric Allen | -- | Michigan State |
| 5 | 115 | Don Croft | DT | Texas-El Paso |
| 6 | 152 | Bruce Laird | DB | American International |
| 7 | 169 | John Sykes | RB | Morgan State |
| 8 | 191 | Al Qualls | -- | Oklahoma |
| 8 | 204 | Van Brownson | -- | Nebraska |
| 9 | 215 | Gary Hambell | -- | Dayton |
| 10 | 256 | Dave Shilling | -- | Oregon State |
| 11 | 282 | Fred DeBernardi | DE | Texas-El Paso |
| 12 | 308 | Gary Theiler | -- | Tennessee |
| 13 | 334 | Herb Washington | -- | Michigan State |
| 14 | 359 | John Morris | -- | Missouri Valley |
| 15 | 386 | Robin Parkhouse | -- | Alabama |
| 16 | 412 | Gary Wichard | -- | C.W. Post |
| 17 | 438 | Stan White | LB | Ohio State |
| 1971 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 22 | Don McCauley | RB | North Carolina |
| 1 | 26 | Lenny Dunlap | DB | North Texas |
| 2 | 52 | Bill Atessis | DE | Texas |
| 3 | 78 | Karl Douglas | -- | Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| 5 | 130 | John Andrews | TE | Indiana |
| 6 | 156 | Ken Frith | -- | Louisiana-Monroe |
| 7 | 182 | Gordon Bowdell | WR | Michigan State |
| 8 | 207 | Willie Bogan | -- | Dartmouth |
| 9 | 234 | Bill Burnett | -- | Arkansas |
| 10 | 260 | Rex Kern | DB | Ohio State |
| 11 | 286 | Dave Jones | -- | Baylor |
| 12 | 294 | Bob Wuensch | -- | Texas |
| 12 | 312 | Bill Triplett | -- | Michigan State |
| 13 | 338 | Tom Neville | -- | Yale |
| 14 | 364 | Mike Mikolayunas | -- | Davidson |
| 15 | 390 | Mike Hogan | -- | Michigan State |
| 16 | 416 | Rich Harrington | -- | Houston |
| 17 | 441 | Don Nottingham | RB | Kent State |
| 1970 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 18 | Norm Bulaich | RB | Texas Christian |
| 2 | 44 | Jim Bailey | DT | Kansas |
| 3 | 70 | Jim O'Brien | WR | Cincinnati |
| 3 | 74 | Ara Person | TE | Morgan State |
| 4 | 95 | Steve Smear | -- | Penn State |
| 5 | 122 | Billy Newsome | DE | Grambling State |
| 6 | 148 | Ron Gardin | DB | Arizona |
| 7 | 174 | Gordon Slade | -- | Davidson |
| 8 | 200 | Bob Bouley | -- | Boston College |
| 9 | 226 | Barney Harris | -- | Texas A&M |
| 10 | 252 | Dick Palmer | LB | Kentucky |
| 11 | 278 | George Edwards | -- | Fairmont State |
| 12 | 304 | Don Burrell | -- | Angelo State |
| 13 | 330 | Dave Polak | -- | Bowling Green State |
| 14 | 356 | Tom Curtis | DB | Michigan |
| 15 | 382 | Phillip Gary | -- | Kentucky State |
| 16 | 408 | Jack Maitland | RB | Williams |
| 17 | 434 | Alvin Pearman | -- | Colgate |
| 1969 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 25 | Eddie Hinton | WR | Oklahoma |
| 2 | 33 | Ted Hendricks | LB | Miami (Fla.) |
| 2 | 51 | Tommy Maxwell | DB | Texas A&M |
| 3 | 77 | Dennis Nelson | T | Illinois State |
| 4 | 87 | Jacky Stewart | -- | Texas Tech |
| 5 | 129 | King Dunlap | -- | Tennessee State |
| 6 | 154 | Bill Fortier | -- | Louisiana State |
| 7 | 163 | Gary Fleming | -- | Samford |
| 7 | 181 | Roland Moss | TE | Toledo |
| 8 | 207 | Sam Havrilak | WR | Bucknell |
| 9 | 210 | George Wright | DT | Sam Houston State |
| 9 | 232 | Larry Good | -- | Georgia Tech |
| 10 | 259 | Marion Griffin | -- | Purdue |
| 11 | 285 | Ken Delaney | -- | Akron |
| 12 | 310 | Butch Riley | LB | Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| 13 | 337 | Carl Mauck | C | Southern Illinois |
| 14 | 363 | Dave Bartelt | -- | Colorado |
| 15 | 389 | George Thompson | -- | Marquette |
| 16 | 415 | Jim McMillan | -- | The Citadel |
| 17 | 441 | Joe Cowan | -- | Johns Hopkins |
| 1968 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 23 | John Williams | OT | Minnesota |
| 2 | 50 | Bob Grant | LB | Wake Forest |
| 3 | 78 | Rich O'Hara | -- | Northern Arizona |
| 4 | 107 | Jim Duncan | DB | Maryland East. Shore |
| 5 | 126 | Paul Elzey | LB | Toledo |
| 7 | 188 | Anthony Andrews | -- | Hampton |
| 8 | 216 | Tommy Davis | -- | Tennessee State |
| 9 | 242 | Terry Cole | RB | Indiana |
| 10 | 257 | Ocie Austin | DB | Utah State |
| 10 | 270 | Ed Tomlin | -- | Hampton |
| 11 | 296 | Bill Pickens | -- | Houston |
| 12 | 324 | James Jackson | -- | Jackson State |
| 13 | 350 | Howie Tennebar | -- | Kent State |
| 14 | 378 | Charles Mitchell | -- | Alabama State |
| 15 | 404 | Jeff Beaver | -- | North Carolina |
| 16 | 432 | Walt Blackledge | -- | San Jose State |
| 17 | 458 | Roy Pederson | -- | Northern Iowa |
| 1967 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | Bubba Smith | DE | Michigan State |
| 1 | 20 | Jim Detwiler | -- | Michigan |
| 2 | 45 | Rick Volk | DB | Michigan |
| 3 | 54 | Norman Davis | G | Grambling State |
| 3 | 71 | Leon Ward | -- | Oklahoma State |
| 4 | 100 | Charlie Stukes | DB | Maryland East. Shore |
| 5 | 126 | Ron Porter | LB | Idaho |
| 6 | 137 | Terry Southall | -- | Baylor |
| 7 | 179 | Bo Rein | -- | Ohio State |
| 8 | 202 | Lee Anderson | -- | Bishop |
| 8 | 204 | Cornelius Johnson | G | Virginia Union |
| 9 | 229 | Ron Kirkland | -- | Nebraska |
| 10 | 258 | Leigh Gilbert | -- | Northern Illinois |
| 12 | 290 | Herman Reed | -- | St. Augustine's |
| 12 | 298 | Preston Pearson | RB | Illinois |
| 12 | 307 | J.B. Christian | -- | Oklahoma State |
| 13 | 335 | Marc Allen | -- | West Texas A&M |
| 14 | 359 | Pat Conley | -- | Purdue |
| 15 | 385 | Bob Wade | DB | Morgan State |
| 16 | 413 | Don Alley | WR | Adams State |
| 1966 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Sam Ball | T | Kentucky | |
| 7 | Ray Perkins | WR | Alabama | |
| 8 | Jerry Allen | RB | Nebraska-Omaha | |
| 14 | Jim Ward | QB | Gettysburg | |
| 1965 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Mike Curtis | LB | Duke | |
| 2 | Ralph Neely | T | Oklahoma | |
| 3 | Glenn Ressler | OG | Penn State | |
| 6 | Bobby Felts | HB | Florida A&M | |
| 8 | Rosey Davis | DE | Tennessee State | |
| 9 | Tom Bleick | DB | Georgia Tech | |
| 10 | George Harold | DB | Allen | |
| 15 | Roy Hilton | DE | Jackson State | |
| 19 | Barry Brown | LB | Florida | |
| 1964 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Marv Woodson | DB | Indiana | |
| 2 | Tony Lorick | RB | Arizona State | |
| 4 | Ted Davis | LB | Georgia Tech | |
| 9 | Vince Turner | DB | Missouri | |
| 18 | Alvin Haymond | DB | Southern University | |
| 1963 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Bob Vogel | T | Ohio State | |
| 2 | Butch Wilson | TE | Alabama | |
| 2 | John Mackey | TE | Syracuse | |
| 4 | Jerry Logan | DB | West Texas A&M | |
| 7 | Willie Richardson | WR | Jackson State | |
| 11 | Winston Hill | T | Texas Southern | |
| 12 | Butch Maples | LB | Baylor | |
| 14 | Neal Petties | WR | San Diego State | |
| 1962 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Wendell Harris | DB | Louisiana State | |
| 2 | Bill Saul | LB | Penn State | |
| 3 | Dan Sullivan | G | Boston College | |
| 7 | Fred Miller | DT | Louisiana State | |
| 12 | Bake Turner | WR | Texas Tech | |
| 19 | Fred Gillett | HB | Los Angeles State | |
| 1961 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Tom Matte | RB | Ohio State | |
| 2 | Tom Gilburg | OT | Syracuse | |
| 3 | Jerry Hill | RB | Wyoming | |
| 4 | Ken Gregory | OE | Whittier | |
| 9 | Pete Nicklas | T | Baylor | |
| 10 | Bob Clemens | FB | Pittsburgh | |
| 1960 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 3 | Jim Welch | DB | Southern Methodist | |
| 8 | Jim Colvin | DT | Houston | |
| 9 | Don Perkins | FB | New Mexico | |
| 10 | Bobby Boyd | DB | Oklahoma | |
| 10 | Ernie Barnes | G | North Carolina Central | |
| 16 | George Boynton | DB | Texas A&M-Commerce | |
| 1959 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Jackie Burkett | LB | Auburn | |
| 2 | Dave Sherer | OE | Southern Methodist | |
| 5 | Don Churchwell | OT | Mississippi | |
| 6 | Palmer Pyle | G | Michigan State | |
| 7 | Hal Lewis | HB | Houston | |
| 11 | Tom Stephens | TE | Syracuse | |
| 12 | Dick Wood | QB | Auburn | |
| 1958 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Lenny Lyles | DB | Louisville | |
| 4 | Les Walters | DB | Penn State | |
| 5 | Ray Brown | DB | Mississippi | |
| 7 | John Diehl | DT | Virginia | |
| 7 | Johnny Sample | DB | Maryland East. Shore | |
| 8 | Floyd Peters | DT | San Francisco State | |
| 12 | Tommy Addison | LB | South Carolina | |
| 13 | Jerry Richardson | FL | Wofford | |
| 14 | Ken Hall | HB | Texas A&M | |
| 16 | Archie Matsos | LB | Michigan State | |
| 1957 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Jim Parker | OT | Ohio State | |
| 2 | Don Shinnick | LB | UCLA | |
| 3 | Luke Owens | DE | Kent State | |
| 6 | Billy Pricer | FB | Oklahoma | |
| 11 | Andy Nelson | DB | Memphis | |
| 13 | Jack Call | HB | Colgate | |
| 15 | Hall Whitley | LB | Texas A&M - Kingsville | |
| 16 | Joe Cannavino | DB | Ohio State | |
| 20 | Walt Livingston | HB | Heidelberg | |
| 1956 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Lenny Moore | HB | Penn State | |
| 8 | Bill Koman | LB | North Carolina | |
| 12 | Steve Myhra | OG | North Dakota | |
| 17 | Bill Danenhauer | DE | Emporia State | |
| 21 | Jim Harness | DB | Mississippi State | |
| 1955 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Alan Ameche | FB | Wisconsin | |
| 1 | 1 | George Shaw | QB | Oregon |
| 2 | Dick Szymanski | C | Notre Dame | |
| 3 | L.G. Dupre | HB | Baylor | |
| 4 | Jack Patera | LB | Oregon | |
| 5 | George Preas | OT | Virginia Tech | |
| 8 | Dale Meinert | LB | Oklahoma State | |
| 9 | Walter Bryan | DB | Texas Tech | |
| 12 | Dick Chorovich | DT | Miami (Ohio) | |
| 15 | Jerry Peterson | DT | Texas | |
| 18 | Charlie Shepard | HB | North Texas | |
| 28 | Bob Myers | DT | Ohio State | |
| 1954 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Cotton Davidson | QB | Baylor | |
| 11 | Bob Leberman | DB | Syracuse | |
| 12 | Don Chelf | T | Iowa | |
| 13 | Chuck McMillan | DB | John Carroll | |
| 14 | Ordell Braase | DE | South Dakota | |
| 16 | Alex Sandusky | OG | Clarion | |
| 20 | Raymond Berry | OE | Southern Methodist | |
| 1953 - Baltimore Colts | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Billy Vessels | HB | Oklahoma | |
| 2 | Bernie Flowers | OE | Purdue | |
| 3 | Buck McPhail | FB | Oklahoma | |
| 5 | Jack Little | OT | Texas A&M | |
| 6 | Jimmy Sears | HB | USC | |
| 24 | Monte Brethauer | DB | Oregon | |
| 1952 - Dallas Texans | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Les Richter | LB | California | |
| 2 | Gino Marchetti | DE | San Francisco | |
| 7 | Johnny Petitbon | DB | Notre Dame | |
| 9 | Jim Lansford | OT | Texas | |
| 11 | Pat Cannamela | LB | USC | |
| 12 | Jim Mutscheller | OE | Notre Dame | |
| 15 | Jack Bighead | DE | Pepperdine | |
| 17 | Dick Horn | QB | Stanford | |
| 19 | Gene Felker | OE | Wisconsin | |
| 22 | Harry Hugasian | HB | Stanford | |
| 1951 - New York Yanks | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 2 | Ken Jackson | OT | Texas | |
| 3 | Mike McCormack | OT | Kansas | |
| 4 | Elmer Wingate | DE | Maryland | |
| 8 | Larry Lauer | C | Alabama | |
| 10 | Jesse Thomas | DB | Michigan State | |
| 21 | Al Pollard | HB | Army | |
| 24 | James Stroschein | DE | UCLA | |
| 26 | Will Sherman | DB | St. Mary's (CA) | |
| 1950 - New York Yanks | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 19 | Bobbie Griffin | DB | Baylor | |
| 1949 - New York Bulldogs | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Doak Walker | HB | Southern Methodist | |
| 2 | Bob DeMoss | QB | Purdue | |
| 5 | Mike Boyda | LB | Washington & Lee | |
| 6 | Rip Collins | HB | Louisiana State | |
| 6 | Sam Tamburo | DE | Penn State | |
| 7 | Pete Wissman | C | St. Louis | |
| 20 | Frank Gaul | T | Notre Dame | |
| 1948 - Boston Yanks | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Vaughn Mancha | C | Alabama | |
| 4 | Phil Slosburg | DB | Temple | |
| 9 | George Roman | DT | Case Western Reserve | |
| 10 | Ab Wimberly | DE | Louisiana State | |
| 11 | Bob Jensen | DE | Iowa State | |
| 18 | Frank Nelson | HB | Utah | |
| 1947 - Boston Yanks | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Fritz Barzilauskas | OG | Yale | |
| 3 | Johnny Rapacz | C | Oklahoma | |
| 4 | Al Baldwin | OE | Arkansas | |
| 6 | George Sullivan | DE | Notre Dame | |
| 7 | Joe Watt | DB | Syracuse | |
| 8 | Bill Chipley | OE | Washington & Lee | |
| 9 | Gene Malinowski | TB | Detroit | |
| 10 | Robert Hazelhurst | HB | Denver | |
| 11 | Alex Sidorik | T | Mississippi State | |
| 13 | Bob Sullivan | HB | Iowa | |
| 29 | Tom Rodgers | T | Bucknell | |
| 30 | John Prchlik | DT | Yale | |
| 1946 - Boston Yanks | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | Boley Dancewicz | QB | Notre Dame |
| 2 | Nick Scollard | DE | St. Joseph's (Ind.) | |
| 3 | Bob McClure | G | Nevada-Reno | |
| 9 | Al Dekdebrun | TB | Cornell | |
| 16 | Bill Swiacki | OE | Columbia | |
| 1945 - Boston Yanks | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 2 | Tom Dean | T | Southern Methodist | |
| 3 | Damon Tassos | G | Texas A&M | |
| 4 | Don Deeks | T | Washington | |
| 6 | Jim Mello | DB | Notre Dame | |
| 8 | Ellis Jones | G | Tulsa | |
| 20 | Mario Gianelli | DG | Boston College | |
| 28 | John Morelli | G | Georgetown | |
| 1944 - Boston Yanks | ||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | 1 | Angelo Bertelli | QB | Notre Dame |
| 2 | 27 | Babe Dimancheff | HB | Purdue |
| 10 | 120 | Ed Fiorentino | DE | Brown |
| 17 | 197 | Art Faircloth | DB | Guilford |
| 29 | 324 | Ralph Calcagni | T | Pennsylvania |