- History
| 1958 - Round 1 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 1 | Chicago Cardinals | King Hill | QB | Rice |
| Chicago Cardinals | John David Crow | HB | Texas A&M | |
| Green Bay Packers | Dan Currie | LB | Michigan State | |
| Cleveland Browns | Jim Shofner | DB | Texas Christian | |
| Baltimore Colts | Lenny Lyles | DB | Louisville | |
| Chicago Bears | Chuck Howley | LB | West Virginia | |
| Los Angeles Rams | Lou Michaels | DE | Kentucky | |
| San Francisco 49ers | Charlie Krueger | DT | Texas A&M | |
| Los Angeles Rams | Jim Phillips | OE | Auburn | |
| Philadelphia Eagles | Walt Kowalczyk | FB | Michigan State | |
| Detroit Lions | Alex Karras | DT | Iowa | |
| San Francisco 49ers | James Pace | HB | Michigan | |
| New York Giants | Phil King | HB | Vanderbilt | |
| 1958 - Round 2 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Philadelphia Eagles | Proverb Jacobs | DT | California | |
| Los Angeles Rams | Clendon Thomas | DB | Oklahoma | |
| Washington Redskins | Mike Sommer | HB | George Washington | |
| Green Bay Packers | Jim Taylor | FB | Louisiana State | |
| Chicago Cardinals | Jim McCusker | OT | Pittsburgh | |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Larry Krutko | FB | West Virginia | |
| New York Giants | Frank Youso | OT | Minnesota | |
| Chicago Bears | Willard Dewveall | OE | Southern Methodist | |
| 1958 - Round 3 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Chicago Bears | Ed Cooke | DE | Maryland | |
| Chicago Bears | Don Healy | DT | Maryland | |
| Washington Redskins | Bill Anderson | OE | Tennessee | |
| Green Bay Packers | Dick Christy | HB | North Carolina State | |
| Cleveland Browns | Buzz Guy | OG | Duke | |
| Los Angeles Rams | Jim Jones | DB | Washington | |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Billy Krisher | OG | Oklahoma | |
| Green Bay Packers | Ray Nitschke | LB | Illinois | |
| 1958 - Round 4 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Chicago Bears | Erich Barnes | DB | Purdue | |
| Los Angeles Rams | John Guzik | LB | Pittsburgh | |
| Baltimore Colts | Les Walters | DB | Penn State | |
| Cleveland Browns | Jim Ninowski | QB | Michigan State | |
| Detroit Lions | Wayne Walker | LB | Idaho | |
| Green Bay Packers | Jerry Kramer | OG | Idaho | |
| 1958 - Round 5 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Green Bay Packers | Joe Francis | QB | Oregon State | |
| Baltimore Colts | Ray Brown | DB | Mississippi | |
| Cleveland Browns | Jim Gibbons | OE | Iowa | |
| Chicago Bears | Bob Jewett | OE | Michigan State | |
| Los Angeles Rams | John Baker | DE | North Carolina Central | |
| New York Giants | Bobby Joe Conrad | WR | Texas A&M | |
| Los Angeles Rams | Frank Ryan | QB | Rice | |
| San Francisco 49ers | Billy Atkins | DB | Auburn | |
| 1958 - Round 6 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Chicago Bears | Merrill Douglas | FB | Utah | |
| Green Bay Packers | Ken Gray | OG | Howard Payne | |
| Los Angeles Rams | Floyd Iglehart | DB | Wiley | |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Dick Lasse | LB | Syracuse | |
| Cleveland Browns | Jim Wulff | DB | Michigan State | |
| New York Giants | Billy Lott | FB | Mississippi | |
| Washington Redskins | Dick Lynch | DB | Notre Dame | |
| San Francisco 49ers | Henry Schmidt | DT | Trinity (Tex.) | |
| Detroit Lions | Dan Lewis | HB | Wisconsin | |
| 1958 - Round 7 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Baltimore Colts | John Diehl | DT | Virginia | |
| Baltimore Colts | Johnny Sample | DB | Maryland East. Shore | |
| Los Angeles Rams | Bill Jobko | LB | Ohio State | |
| Chicago Cardinals | Jon Jelacic | DE | Minnesota | |
| Cleveland Browns | Bobby Mitchell | FL | Illinois | |
| 1958 - Round 8 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| San Francisco 49ers | Leon Burton | HB | Arizona State | |
| Detroit Lions | Phil Blazer | G | North Carolina | |
| New York Giants | Don Sutherin | DB | Ohio State | |
| Detroit Lions | Karl Koepfer | OG | Bowling Green State | |
| Philadelphia Eagles | Bill Striegel | OG | U. of Pacific | |
| Baltimore Colts | Floyd Peters | DT | San Francisco State | |
| 1958 - Round 9 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Chicago Bears | Ralph Anderson | OE | Los Angeles State | |
| Detroit Lions | Ben Paolucci | DT | Wayne State (Mich.) | |
| Washington Redskins | Frank Kuchta | C | Notre Dame | |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Mike Henry | LB | USC | |
| Cleveland Browns | Bernie Parrish | DB | Florida | |
| 1958 - Round 10 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Philadelphia Eagles | Theron Sapp | HB | Georgia | |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Dick Campbell | LB | Marquette | |
| 1958 - Round 11 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Washington Redskins | Darrell Dess | OG | North Carolina State | |
| San Francisco 49ers | Hogan Wharton | G | Houston | |
| Chicago Cardinals | Dean Philpott | FB | Fresno State | |
| 1958 - Round 12 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Cleveland Browns | Bob Brodhead | QB | Duke | |
| Chicago Bears | Johnny Morris | FL | California-Santa Barbara | |
| Baltimore Colts | Tommy Addison | LB | South Carolina | |
| 1958 - Round 13 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| New York Giants | Don Herndon | HB | Tampa | |
| Baltimore Colts | Jerry Richardson | FL | Wofford | |
| Chicago Cardinals | Charlie Jackson | DB | Southern Methodist | |
| 1958 - Round 14 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Baltimore Colts | Ken Hall | HB | Texas A&M | |
| Philadelphia Eagles | Bill Lapham | C | Iowa | |
| Detroit Lions | Ken Webb | HB | Presbyterian | |
| Chicago Cardinals | Bob Schmidt | C | Minnesota | |
| New York Giants | C.R. Roberts | FB | USC | |
| 1958 - Round 15 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Washington Redskins | Jack Davis | G | Maryland | |
| 1958 - Round 16 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Cleveland Browns | Jerry Cornelison | T | Southern Methodist | |
| San Francisco 49ers | George Shirkey | DT | Stephen F. Austin St. | |
| Baltimore Colts | Archie Matsos | LB | Michigan State | |
| 1958 - Round 17 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| San Francisco 49ers | John Wittenborn | OG | Southeast Missouri State | |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Joe Lewis | DT | Compton CC CA | |
| 1958 - Round 18 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| San Francisco 49ers | Dennit Morris | LB | Oklahoma | |
| 1958 - Round 19 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Los Angeles Rams | Dick Dorsey | WR | Oklahoma | |
| Chicago Bears | Bill Roehnelt | LB | Bradley | |
| Chicago Cardinals | Sonny Randle | OE | Virginia | |
| Philadelphia Eagles | Ron Sabal | OT | Purdue | |
| 1958 - Round 20 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| San Francisco 49ers | Jerry Mertens | DB | Drake | |
| 1958 - Round 21 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| 244 | Philadelphia Eagles | John Madden | -- | Cal Poly-S.L.O. |
| Detroit Lions | Jim Wagstaff | DB | Idaho State | |
| Washington Redskins | Jackie Simpson | LB | Mississippi | |
| Chicago Bears | Bill Miller | DT | New Mexico Highlands | |
| 1958 - Round 22 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Cleveland Browns | Bob Renn | HB | Florida State | |
| 1958 - Round 24 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Detroit Lions | Dave Whitsell | DB | Indiana | |
| San Francisco 49ers | Dee Mackey | TE | Texas A&M-Commerce | |
| 1958 - Round 26 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Jon Evans | OE | Oklahoma State | |
| 1958 - Round 28 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| New York Giants | Bob Watters | DE | Lincoln (MO) | |
| 1958 - Round 29 | ||||
| SEL # | TEAM | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL |
| Philadelphia Eagles | Don McDonald | DB | Houston | |
